Public Advisory: Baja Racks, 5th generation 4Runner.

CuStOm

Adventurer
Also posted on T4R.org.....

First off I do not want to turn this into a bashing thread or "baja sucks" thread. I merely wan't others on here to be educated when researching rack options for their own vehicles.

This rack has been installed for a year and the only thing mounted to it was a James Baroud tent that weigh's 130lbs, a Fiamma awning that is mounted with the Baja brackets that weigh's 19lbs. The combined weight of the two people sleeping in the tent is 270lbs.

I recently removed the tent and rack from the vehicle to re-position the tent on the rack. This is when I discovered issue 2 below.

Issue 1:
Driving down the paved highway, one of the awning brackets broke. Luckily the window was down and we were only traveling 35mph and the passenger was able to grab it when we heard the snap and no further damage to the vehicle occurred. After a couple weeks of me chasing them and correspondence, they sent me new brackets that were redesigned and much stronger for free. I cannot say the process was good but the end result was acceptable customer service.
tRifYqA.jpg


Issue 2:
The Baja Utility rack has dented the top of my 4Runner in 6 places. On all four corners the outside of the feet have dented the roof. On the two rear rear ones it has also dented the roof from the inside edge of the feet. This was not noticeable when the rack was mounted to the vehicle. With that said, I am curious how many other people have removed their rack and have or have not found dents? I am curious if this is just a manufacturing problem with my rack or a design/jig issue that would result in more people experiencing the issue. My guess is that most people do not remove their rack once installed so there's potentially many others that might not know. This is really the intent of this thread, awareness and education.

5wfbSCJ.jpg

YmZmF2d.jpg

v6R8NhG.jpg


What I think the problem is, and unfortunately I didn't take a picture of the bottom of the racks feet where the touch the car, is either the angles of the feet do not match the angle of the sheet metal OR the small steel tubes that come down into the channel are not long enough. These tubes are welded to the bottom of the feet and allow the rack to stand off the car the correct amount. This tube is where the rack bolts into the stock mounting holes. The solution below is what I came up with and appears to put the rack into the proper position. This is a 1/4" piece of aluminum, so quite the distance to correct the manufacturing/design issue. The rack has always been installed using the Toyota recommended torque. Baja did not specify a torque nor did they have one when I called upon original installation.
qoTTKae.jpg


I have several very professional emails to Baja with their Sales, Engineering and Support email addresses along with Sergio Murillo's business email without ANY response to the issue. Over the course of the last 3 weeks all 4 email address were cc'd on all correspondence. ZERO response. They were sent the same pictures you see here. One voice mail was also left. My time spent reaching out has been exhausted. From my perspective this is horrible customer service.

I hope the people here find this of some value and education. Even more I hope I am the only person with a brand new 4Runner that has significant dents on its roof from using this product.
 

jeverich

Luddite
Well that certainly sucks.

Apart from the people that go on a tirade over a seemingly minuscule issue; it seems that you've got a valid case where the initial R&D on a product might've actually caused a failure...

That's BS to get no response - especially after you've waited more than long enough for a professional operation to respond.

Hope you get somewhere - I'm sure those dents won't help re-sale.

Perhaps the admins here could assist and offer a little leverage? I'm not on here anywhere near enough to know if Baja is a forum supporter or not...

Good luck.
 

tacollie

Glamper
A local guy I knew had the same issue with the denting. He also had a serious rust issue. I know he had a hard time getting Bajarack to address the rust but in the end they did pay to get the rack recoated. Keep bugging them.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

bkg

Explorer
I have zero dog in this fight, but after reading and looking at the pictures I have to ask... How was this not noticed during installation?
 

CuStOm

Adventurer
I have zero dog in this fight, but after reading and looking at the pictures I have to ask... How was this not noticed during installation?

The feet from the rack hide it. It's very difficult to tell this has occurred when the rack is on the car. It's one of those things that you'd have to know it was there to notice.
 

Martinjmpr

Wiffleball Batter
To me this illustrates the problem of roof racks. Racks get heavier and capable of more stuff but the roofs they are bolted onto do not.
.
Seems to me the issue is not with Baja Racks, as I would imagine that any kind of rack that is attached in this manner and carrying this kind of weight would likely do the same thing.
.
Quite simply, the problem is you are putting more weight on the roof than the roof is designed to carry. And short of reinforcing the roof somehow, there's no "fix" that's going to work. Back in the 70's when sheet metal was heavier and thicker you could put more weight on the roof but nowadays manufacturers want the sheet metal to be as light as possible, both to save on materials and to save on weight.
.
Toyota never designed that roof to be able to carry 300+ lbs, and particularly with a RTT, think about what happens as you sleep: you move around, toss and turn, etc, and every time you do that, that weight is transferred through those mounting feet onto the roof. Put enough weight on that and it's going to deform, I don't care how well made or designed the roof rack is.
 

CuStOm

Adventurer
To me this illustrates the problem of roof racks. Racks get heavier and capable of more stuff but the roofs they are bolted onto do not.
.
Seems to me the issue is not with Baja Racks, as I would imagine that any kind of rack that is attached in this manner and carrying this kind of weight would likely do the same thing.
.
Quite simply, the problem is you are putting more weight on the roof than the roof is designed to carry. And short of reinforcing the roof somehow, there's no "fix" that's going to work. Back in the 70's when sheet metal was heavier and thicker you could put more weight on the roof but nowadays manufacturers want the sheet metal to be as light as possible, both to save on materials and to save on weight.
.
Toyota never designed that roof to be able to carry 300+ lbs, and particularly with a RTT, think about what happens as you sleep: you move around, toss and turn, etc, and every time you do that, that weight is transferred through those mounting feet onto the roof. Put enough weight on that and it's going to deform, I don't care how well made or designed the roof rack is.

I disagree. The spacers under the feet, if properly manufactured with proper quality control, should prohibit the sheet metal from being touched/impacted.

From Baja's website "Load Capacity: Dynamic (while driving) 300Lb (136 kg); Static 600Lb (272 kg)". Load capacities of the rack do not include the 80lbs of the rack itself. The dynamic state of the setup is approximately 160lbs at best with the bedding and whatnot inside the closed tent. When were parked and occupying the tent the load on the rack is at most 460lbs with people and personal affects.

http://bajarack.com/?id=racks_list&model=18
 

bkg

Explorer
But what is the rating of the 4runner roof? Can it really handle 300-600# only a few inches of support? I think that's a good question.
 

jeverich

Luddite
But what is the rating of the 4runner roof? Can it really handle 300-600# only a few inches of support? I think that's a good question.

I agree. Seems the Baja only addressed the strength of their rack; which is pretty easy to ascertain. Hell, I could build a rack out of schedule 80 pipe that would have a capacity of 1,000 lbs.!

Yet, unless Baja has done some form of finite analysis on the roof of the 4Runner and their components, I'd say that their numbers are pure conjecture.
 

Ratman1979

Observer
I installed their rack on my 2014 Tacoma and ended up with some similar dents, I think 2 or 3 spots. I never put any load on the rack and I followed their provided instructions. I removed the rack soon after the first drive as the noise level was unacceptable. I didn't notice the dents until after it was removed.
 

CuStOm

Adventurer
I installed their rack on my 2014 Tacoma and ended up with some similar dents, I think 2 or 3 spots. I never put any load on the rack and I followed their provided instructions. I removed the rack soon after the first drive as the noise level was unacceptable. I didn't notice the dents until after it was removed.
Thanks
 

Dances with Wolves

aka jk240sx
Looking at your pictures, I can see that the silver rectangular spacer is below the roof surface. That would be a red flag to me right off the bat. I don't think any rack base should be wider than it's mounting point.

I've only used a basket system once on a previous vehicle. I used Yakima tracks with control towers. I used it with rafts and mountain bikes. It wasn't low profile, but it didn't damage the roof either.
 

chmura

Adventurer
Looking at your pictures, I can see that the silver rectangular spacer is below the roof surface. That would be a red flag to me right off the bat. I don't think any rack base should be wider than it's mounting point.

I've only used a basket system once on a previous vehicle. I used Yakima tracks with control towers. I used it with rafts and mountain bikes. It wasn't low profile, but it didn't damage the roof either.

Exactly!

When I was shopping for full length racks for my 4runner I noticed the mounting feet on the Baja extended out to the painted surfaces of the 4runner roof line. This is was HUGE problem for me and did not make sense at all. So if the spacers below the mounting plate are to short and someone is tightening down the nuts you probably are applying force to the sides of the painted surface of the roof and are denting your roof the more you are tightening down! I do not believe this is a weight issue. As I had 600lbs sleeping with 3 people on my 4runner using a Gobi. This is a DESIGN issue. Look at the pic below. That mounting plate does not make any sense at all over hanging to the left and right of the rain gutter mounting location.

71000d1347135746-anyone-have-closeup-pics-baja-rack-mounting-plates-rear-passenger-side.jpg


I purchased a Gobi Rack had it for 2 years removed it without a problem a ding, scratch, etc. Sold the Gobi for good amount. I am now using a K9 2.2m rack with the mounting feet staying inside the rain gutter area as well.
 
Last edited:

MattScott

Approved Vendor
I just forwarded this over to Sergio.

I have the same rack and haven't had any issues and we've spent plenty of time in it.

As far as weight goes, I use a James Baroud RTT on it and have 4 MAXTRAX on the roof, and we frequently sleep in it (girlfriend and I).
 

Forum statistics

Threads
186,369
Messages
2,885,035
Members
226,303
Latest member
guapstyle
Top