What kind of LED's are they? Cree makes a lot of different emitters (XP-G, XM-L, XP-E...). Maybe post a picture of them. That will also show how they are attached.
For a bare emitter shipped quickly check out Digikey or Mouser, if you want the newest and brightest bins check Cutter electronics. They're in Australia but have a great selection of different bins and color temperatures.
Cree "bins" their LED's by brightness, so you'll see things like R2, T6, U2, etc. It's just the lumen range of the LED, so for example a Cree XM-L with a T6 bin will emit between 280 and 300 lumens @ 700 mA.
A warning though, if you replace a cool tint LED with a warmer tint that offers better color rendition you'll be spoiled and want to upgrade all of them...