New Subaru Outback or Explorer?

[BlackdogGS]

We are car shopping and were considering an Explorer or Subaru. We looked at but did not drive the Explorer and really liked it, we have owned Fords for over 35 years. We're very comfortable with Ford, gas and tires have been our only expenses, never had one in the shop for and reason.

I looked at the Subaru last night and liked it. I like the size of the Explorer better but hey, the Outback is $10,000 less. After I got home I researched it on the Internet and was surprised by the amount of issues this car has. The problem I'm most concerned with is the oil consumption. Do any of you know if this issue has been resolved? If so are the 2015-2016 models ok?

At this point I'm still researching.

Thanks!

 

[freshlikesushi]

There is no oil consumption issue in the 15+
there are very isolated instances

it was a big issue in the 10-14 but no real reports except for a few people on forums. It is a 1qt acceptable consumption between oil chances.
Past that, i own, wheel, and have extensively modified my 2015 outback with zero issues.

I also have a 500$ coupon if you are buying very soon i can send you

 

[tarditi]

I had a Subaru WRX and they are a great brand. I've had checkered experience with Fords, but the new Explorer looks nice (treat it as a crossover, not a body-on-frame SUV).

We're in the market ourselves, and considering the Outback or Forester to replace my wife's 2WD GMC Acadia.
We like the smaller size, all-weather capability, and fuss-free interior of the Subarus, but they still have the comfortable amenities.

 

[BlackdogGS]

This is from the Subaru Outback forum: http://www.subaruoutback.org/forums/138-gen-5-2015-present/264922-2015-issues-fixed-2016-a.html

An oil burner would be a deal breaker for me but I think that issue has been resolved. Fresh: thanks for the info, we're looking at a new one today and I might take you up on the coupon!

 

[freshlikesushi]

eyesight alone makes subaru a huge asset

 

[BlackdogGS]

Ended up getting the Highlander.

 

[freshlikesushi]

well thats interesting

 

[calicamper]

There is no oil consumption issue in the 15+
there are very isolated instances

it was a big issue in the 10-14 but no real reports except for a few people on forums. It is a 1qt acceptable consumption between oil chances.
Past that, i own, wheel, and have extensively modified my 2015 outback with zero issues.

I also have a 500$ coupon if you are buying very soon i can send you

2010-12 was the old 2.5 no oil use history with that engine. The 3.6 either. The 2013 new ground up 2.5s had some teething issues and oil consumption numbers. If you need load hauling ability go Ford. If its just you and a passenger or two the 2015+ Subarus are fine.

 

[Apdl]

well thats interesting

Hahaha

 

[WagoneerSX4]

They're using 0w20 oil, there will always be oil consumption issues. As long as the consumption falls under Subaru's "normal consumption" amount, nobody seems to care.

 

[Dake21]

well thats interesting

To say the least hahaha!

 

[camodog]

I thought the op was my brother at first. He too is cross shopping an outback and explorer. I didn't see the highlander coming though.

 

[freshlikesushi]

Me either.

DIdnt know they made they anymore haah