Salt and Pepper shaker recommendations?

Kerensky97

Xterra101
An odd question but hear me out.

What GOOD salt and pepper shakers are people using out there for their camp setups? I'm currently using these GSI salt and pepper shakers ( http://amzn.to/2u176Md ) and I hate them with a passion! Poorly designed camp equipment pisses me off and these take the cake out of the many contenders.

First off you have to be careful what cap you put on because the holes on some are too big and the holes on others are too small.
Second the salt or pepper gets past the shaker and pools under the lid if they're upside down (and since they're on opposite ends one will always be upside down). Then when you open the top the excess spills out and suddenly you added 1/4tsp of pepper to a dish that shouldn't have pepper in it (like you were going to put pepper on your scrambled eggs but opened it over your Apple+Cinnamon Oatmeal! True story.)
Then the shakers have a tenancy to come off while closed so that when you unscrew the lid the whole thing comes off as one piece and you have to pry the shaker top out of the threads with the tines of a fork to put it back on.

Screw these cheap pieces of trash! People have been recreation camping for a century now; I want something that works and works well.

- I don't want to have a full size salt and pepper shaker/grinder from the store because I don't use that much spice in a season. For it's flaws the GSI is the perfect size.
- It doesn't have to be full on waterproof but humidity proof is a must. Being nearly airtight helps a lot to keep the spices fresh since they'll probably get lots of temperature swings being in your chuck box all season.
- I'd prefer snap shut tops to the screw on tops. If I'm busy cooking I don't want to have to fumble with getting the thing opened while my food starts to burn.
- It needs to be individually refillable or multiple small shakers. Those 6 in one spice containers seem conveniently compact and appealing until you find out you use way more salt than anything else and end up having to buy another separate container just for that.

If you remember those old 35mm Film Canister shaker caps those were ideal. But they seem to be discontinued.
I also liked those mini Morton Salt and Pepper shakers that were an inch tall. Not good for adding a tbsp of salt to a dish but great for seasoning meals in an ultralight-backpacking setup.

How can we live in a world where you can send live video of yourself from a mountain top using a GPS enabled mini computer phone but the design of our camping gear is actually getting worse?
 

tadg

New member
How about: https://www.amazon.com/Swiss-Advance-sw-sp-Swiss-Spice-Pepper/dp/B000BS5IXA/

Or the Tupperware version of that: https://www.amazon.com/Tupperware-Personal-Pepper-Shaker-Pocket/dp/B00IEGFK9I/

When I was a kid, my parents had one of these for camping:
il_340x270.1276323763_t6yb.jpg
but that is apparently vintage, Hmm, memories..... I'll have to keep my eye out for one.

T
 

swduncan

Observer
Mix in some uncooked rice to absorb humidity and keep things flowing. The old style glass shakers with metal tops you see in restaurants are easy to fill and clean, and you can see what's in them. They're neither light nor tactical, or titanium, but they work. And at the end of the season you can clean them out.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

OCD Overland

Explorer

NatersXJ6

Explorer
Yup. First world problems. I'm glad to have gotten to a point in life when things like this seem to be big problems. I've been considering the same shaker dilemma lately.

I'm thinking of using prescription pill bottles. I really don't need the "shaker" and just need a waterproof way to store spices that won't spill while bouncing around in the back of the camp kitchen.
 

Corey

OverCamping Specialist
IMG_0018.jpgIMG_0018.jpgI would go for those Tupperware ones, they are about the same size of this set that came with a Mt. Rainier National Park bench that was given to my X and me 30+ years ago.
I take it camping every time with me.

By the way, first time I have added an attachment with a pic I just took while on my iPad Air :D

The shakers work great, and top part where the salt comes out looks identical to the Tupperware ones.
 

krick3tt

Adventurer
I have had, for years, two plastic film canisters (hard to find in a digital world) with tops that say P and S.
For the life of me I cannot figure out why this subject causes so much concern. Take a few of the paper ones from the next McDonalds you pass and call it a day.
 

4xdog

Explorer
I have a set of those mini-Tupperware containers linked by OCD Overland that are at least fifty years old -- we used them camping when I was a little kid -- and they still work fine.
71Prk%2BIFYVL._SX450_.jpg


But I also have a compartment in my plastic kitchen utensil Plano box that's stocked with fast-food salt/pepper/Cajun Sparkle, which I gotta admit is a fine solution in today's world.
 

Herbie

Rendezvous Conspirator
I've been at this so long, I still have the little shaker-caps that snap onto 35mm film cans. Try finding those (or film cans) any more!

Only use that for salt, though. I'm a stickler for fresh pepper, so I use the prepackaged McCormicks with the built-in grinder, and pitch whatever is left after somewhere between two seasons and a year. (Seems to depend on how much time I've spent in the desert - you can taste pepper that's lost it's oils.)
 

Forum statistics

Threads
185,884
Messages
2,879,165
Members
225,450
Latest member
Rinzlerz
Top