Thanks to both sgt rock and JPK. I now have this '07 Rubi with 35's, 5:13's, auto, all the usual armor, etc... (Pics here:
http://www.expeditionportal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=57223 ) I love those kinds of trips, but the reality is that I need to cross country(minimum of Iowa, Nebraska, and parts of Colorado) to get to where I'm going. Not many deserts in the midwest. It is these hauls down the interstate that just drive me nuts. I carry an extra 13gal of gas in a tank behind the axle, so I at least have decent range now. I only get 13-14mpg(as low as 10, high as 17) with the 3.8 as it is. I have no idea how sgt rock can get 20. Must drive slower than I do by a lot. Comes back to the need to get there in two days not three.
Anyway, I've been tossing around the decision between a RIPP or a Hemi for over a year. I just want to be able to cruise down the interstate with traffic. The 3.8 in my Jeep can't do that without a tail wind. I'm pretty sure we all know how often that happens....
mikE(thanks again for the answers)
It was my interstate driving that was the deciding factor on my Hemi swap. My hunting clubs are a couple hours away via intersate and so are the mountains. I got tired of the highway performance and ride of my LJ and started borrowing my wife's JKU Rubicon. That was a huge improvement, but I got tired of the Jeep not being able to maintain speed on the interstate and the auto trans always making that dramatic shift down out of O/D.
After looking for alternatives I gave AEV a call and told them that what I was looking for was a Jeep that was the comfortable and brainless highway cruiser that my Suburban is but that was as capable off road as my LJ when I got where I was heading.
Jeff Clark of AEV's answer was, "Well, that's what we do..." They delivered!
My wife's JKU Rubicon has a 2.5" Teraflex BB, spidertrax spacers and is otherwise stock. All in average is 17-18mpg with variable light to medium loads.
M JKU averages 12-13mpg with generally heavier loads. My LJ, with the 4.0, averages about the same, or maybe worse.
More than half of your JKU problem is with the auto trans, imo. Its a three speed auto with third at 1:1 and then a too damn big leap to O/D fourth at ~.69:1. The Hemi trans is a five speed with a gear between the JKU's third and fourth. So the top gear in the five speed is close to the top gear in the JKU four speed, actually slightly taller at ~.67:1, but the huge gap between the four speed's top two gears is gone. The difference is very significant.
Before committing to a Hemi swap, you may want to look into the coming '12's which will have the Pentastar, which will offer ~30% more HP and torque than the 3.8l but most impotantly will also offer a five or six speed auto trans.
I believe that the five or six speed trans will eliminate almost all of the issues that auto JKU's face now and most of the griping about performance. The Pentastar will be a nice bump up, but the trans will be the real leap forward.
I think the cost of trading out of your 2007 and into a 2012 would be less than the cost of going Hemi.
If Jeep would offer the JKU with a V8 engine that put out ~300 HP and lbs/ft of torque it would be perfect. At 375 hp and ft/lbs the Hemi is more than enough. Unfortunately, the Pentastar isn't going to be the perfect Jeep engine because it will still be a bit light on power, but mostly because its HP and torque are produced futher up the rpm band.
If you do decide to go Hemi, than I have to recomend AEV for the swap, or their premium swap kit. One thing to ponder: The Hemi puts out more torque at 1200rpm than the 3.8l puts out max.
JPK