Again, your "mileage" may vary, but your (and your parents?) experiences do not lend any more explanation to 'why' things work the way they do. You simply state that's the way it works and decry my explanation of the way things are constructed on a chemical level.
http://www.edmunds.com/fuel-economy/to-save-money-on-gas-stop-buying-premium.html
http://www.caranddriver.com/features/regular-or-premium-test-results-page-2
The above articles don't support my claim on fouling but it does mention the behavior of premium formulation versus regular, so you can see that my *** is a part of me that paid attention in chemistry class.
Original poster, have you tried running in an intake cleaner (like old school Seafoam) through the brake booster line until the smoke screen starts, shutting down for an hour or so, then driving the cr@p out of it until it clears up? This can have the effect of clearing out a lot of build-up, a non-technical term. I'd change the oil after that, too, in case of blow-by.
John B.