The 225/65/17 tire is the stock tire size. Over on subaruoutback.org the biggest anyone goes is 245/65/17 because the wheel wells do not allow for any larger diameter. I have the 2.5 and I average 26 with 235/65/17 AT's, typically the 3.6's I see average 20-22 overall. I would think you could still expect 28 on the highway with the larger tires, just worse city performance.