Titanium knives

StumpXJ

SE Expedition Society
I love Ti knives. My favorite at this point:

4747d9614fa4d0c4f9015a488e35e314.jpg


CRKT knives are awesome.

Thanks for the link, those are really nice as well!

~James
 

ntsqd

Heretic Car Camper
From machining it Ti behaves a lot like 300 series stainless. Is it also as poor as 300 series for holding an edge?
 

greybrick

Adventurer
ntsqd said:
From machining it Ti behaves a lot like 300 series stainless. Is it also as poor as 300 series for holding an edge?

From various knife and other metal sites it looks like some of the Beta Titanium alloys have about the same Rockwell hardness as good tool steel. There are enough reputable knife companies making Ti knives but if holding an edge was an issue they couldn't sell them I think; probably just a matter of finding the right Ti alloy.

.
 

StumpXJ

SE Expedition Society
Not sure of all of the metallurgy stuff, you guys seem to have a handle on it, but I have two Ti knives, and they hold an edge great!

~James
 

greybrick

Adventurer
I phoned the order desk at TicoTitanium to see if they have beta alloys in plate;

http://www.ticotitanium.com/plate.php#sheet

No luck as Tico only supplies high tensile beta Ti alloys in bar stock, but the order desk gal suggested calling Supra Titanium for alloy plate. I'd like to track down a few pieces of a beta Ti alloy to hand make a couple of skeleton knives, a machete and maybe a couple of other tools.

http://www.supraalloys.com/index.html

Any suggestions welcomed.

.
 
Last edited:

gearbox

Adventurer
greybrick said:
For those who need super lightweight knives here are a couple more Titanium designs from Ocean Master, half the weight of steel;

http://www.oceanmaster.com/KnivesFeatures.htm#Server

I like the folding knife for it's small package and relative safety.

.
Consider a Benchmade with Axis-Lock. They can be small and are more "safe" than those, not to mention they are faster and have the ergos and design quality and engineering from a million-dollar company. A good steel alloy like 154CM or S30V will be fine for everything except leaving in a wet bag.
Titanium is rarely worth it due to the huge cost versus minor weight savings and corrosion resistance.
 

ntsqd

Heretic Car Camper
It amazed me to find Ti being touted as "Corrosion-Proof" and words to that effect. Does the knife industry not know about chlorine based solvents (1, 1, 1; etc.) and their tendency to cause interior (invisible) corrosion salts in Titanium? The aircraft industry forbids the use of those solvents just for this reason. One aircraft parts vendor I know of isn't allowed to have any such solvents on the property.
 

gearbox

Adventurer
greybrick said:
Thanks Gearbox. I'm still looking for suppliers of reasonably priced Ti plate and products though. Here is a big list of various Ti metal and manufactured item suppliers in the US and abroad;

http://www.titan-japan.com/indexe.htm

Interestingly for a Japanese made product these Ti pots and pans from the Horie company don't look to be too expensive;

http://www.horie.co.jp/english/goldpan_e.htm

.
I wish you the best luck in your quest. DIY is a great thing! However, something tells me the alloy for pots and pans may leave something to be desired in the arena of edge-holding ability. You could find out by buying a $9 spork at REI and sharpening the handle :sombrero:
Who knows what heat treating to give it, but I'm sure there are several internet forums dedicated to knife-making and surely a few aficianados of Ti.
If it would help I have a chunk of Ti-6AL-4V lying around that you could try to sharpen and dull. I don't know what heat treatment it has received, nor am I very knowledgeable in general about Ti, despite working with it.

titanium.jpg
 

gearbox

Adventurer
ntsqd said:
It amazed me to find Ti being touted as "Corrosion-Proof" and words to that effect. Does the knife industry not know about chlorine based solvents (1, 1, 1; etc.) and their tendency to cause interior (invisible) corrosion salts in Titanium? The aircraft industry forbids the use of those solvents just for this reason. One aircraft parts vendor I know of isn't allowed to have any such solvents on the property.
In addition, there are restrictions on lead, silver and cadmium, I believe. I've been told any of those can cause inter-granular stress corrosion and/or hydrogen propagation/cracks. Welding is done with a pure argon flood or, in electron beam processes, a very high vacuum.
 
Doesn't really apply much but I did find out by mistake that you can put Titanium in the microwave without any ill effects. It doesn't heat up much, doesn't do the lightning show that steel does. This was with the MSR titanium forks and spoons.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
188,006
Messages
2,900,983
Members
229,320
Latest member
SMBRoamer
Top