I don't mean to high-jack Corey's thread here but I'll add some reviews.
These two items go hand-in-hand for me and how I intend to use them as my camping lighting "system."
Rayovac Sportsman Extreme lantern (SE3DLN)
It's a 300 lumen, LED lantern that operates on three D cell batteries. At full bright it'll run for 72 hrs and 150 hrs for half bright. So, with 3 D cells, figure 4 hrs of light per night i'll run for ~ 2 weeks of use at full bright. The lantern is reasonably compact standing maybe 7-8" tall and about a 3.5" x 3.5" foot print. The lantern feels
solid with a quality heavy plastic housing with molded rubber elements. The top handle is specially shaped so that it'll fold flat against the side of the lantern when down. The primary lens can be removed and a hook popped out of the bottom so the lantern can be hung upside down in a tent or from a lantern stand (see below).
This is a bit of a surprise at how solid and sturdy this little bugger feels. And the light out put is very good. We had two CFL-based four D cell lanters and this Rayovac unit puts out about 50% more power just by eyeballing the two different types of lanterns side-by-side (and it's almost half the physical size, too). And if you want it even brighter, take off the outer lens.
Pros
- Incredibly bright, 300 lumen lantern
- Compact-ish size
- Solid, rugged construction
- Removable lense / hook in base for flexible usage
- LONG battery run time
- Requires fewer batteries than other lanterns.
- Excellent value at ~$25.
Cons
- Um, it'd be cool if it had a remote control the way I've seen on a couple other lanterns
- Can't find it locally in stores (stupid stores . . . )
Colman Lantern Stand
Corey had a previous review of this and partly after asking him some further questions I ordered my own.
This is a folding lanterns stand with a steel tri-pod base and telescoping aluminum main pole. At the top is a flip-out hook for hanging camping lanterns. The unit extends to a hair over 7 ft tall. It comes with some stakes and a long draw string stuff sack type carry bag. When folded it's approximately the size of a typical folding camp chair (length) when folded up but not quite as bulky. The telescoping mechanism are three segments with a twist-n-lock method of securing them. The legs are flat-stock steel instead of some profiled or round tube stock but they seem reasonably heavy duty.
This cost a bit more than the Rayovac lantern but I'm really excited about deploying this equipment on the next camping trip. It gets the lantern up high enough that it casts a good amount of light around a camp site. I'll help quite a bit with meal prep or general comfort at the campsite.
Pros
- Handy for raising a lantern to a decently tall height
- Folds up compact enough to toss next to folding camp chairs
- Sturdy-enough steel and aluminum construction
Cons
- The screw knob to lock the leg collar into position . . . it would be nice if it had metal threaded insert vs. the nylon threads.
The outer lens has been detached from the lantern and
it's hanging upside down by the tent hook.
I like the combo of the lantern stand and the Rayovac
unit, it's like my own portable street light.
No more cooking or camp prep by head light.
I've used propane lanterns in the past but I've never liked them. Their light out put is amazing but the mantles seem rather delicate and I'm always worried about fracturing or shattering the glass lenses. Oh, and they tend to be bulky. Over all, they're not worth the hassle for their light out put, IMO. This Rayovac unit will run longer on it's three D cells than a propane lanter on a charge of propane. It's smaller, and much more rugged, too vs. the gas lanterns.
UPDATE 10-31-2012 After a season of camping I must say I love this combo. It sets up easily and quickly. The lanter stand is plenty stable with the light weight Rayovac up there. And with it hung upside down with the lanter lens removed it just cranks out the light. PLENTY of light for around the camp. We've been setting up the lantern between the cargo deck / camp table and the chuck box and it provides excellent task lighting for cooking duties at night. Then we leave the light on for hours through the evening. After a few camping trips there hasn't been a need to change the batteries. Probably one need to either for another 1-2 years. And the lantern is nice and compact.
I still highly recommend the combo for campsite lighting.
.