Stove or Grill or...What do you use and Why?

computeruser

Explorer
I've been really pleased with this little Coleman multi-fuel unit. I've been content traveling with this stove, a skillet, and a saucepan for boiling water. Judiciously packed, the entire cooking kit, extra Coleman fuel, plus full dish cleaning gear, can fit in a single file box-sized container, with a bit of room to spare.

I'd probably go for a larger stove if I didn't have a Jeep Wrangler, but this one gets the job done nicely and only cost about $50.

533A700_500.jpg
 

Green Ganesha

Adventurer
benedmonson said:
I stopped by wal-mart the other day and found the Brinkmann 2 burner stanless steel for only $40.00! If it is able to work off of larger propane tank with an optional hose then it might be a winner for under $50.00!!! I'm researching the adapter for using it with a 5 LB. propane tank now if anybody has any input on it.

Ben,

I have one of those stoves, and went through a series of headaches getting it to work with larger propane tanks. Things may have changed in the last couple years, but check your owner's manual. When I bought mine (actually it came installed on a first-generation Campa trailer), the instructions warned not to use anything except 14.1-oz. or 16.4-oz. LP cylinders. Paradoxically, Brinkmann did sell a bulk-cylinder adapter. However, when connected to a 11-pound propane tank, the stove barely lit, and could only muster a very impotent simmer. The Campa engineers actually redesigned Brinkmann's adapter, changing the characteristics of an internal spring. This fixed the problem, but Brinkmann was uninterested in incorporating Campa's redesign.

Long story short, I ended up switching to the Partner Steel stove.
 

benedmonson

Disabled Adventurer
Green Ganesha said:
Ben,

I have one of those stoves, and went through a series of headaches getting it to work with larger propane tanks. Things may have changed in the last couple years, but check your owner's manual. When I bought mine (actually it came installed on a first-generation Campa trailer), the instructions warned not to use anything except 14.1-oz. or 16.4-oz. LP cylinders. Paradoxically, Brinkmann did sell a bulk-cylinder adapter. However, when connected to a 11-pound propane tank, the stove barely lit, and could only muster a very impotent simmer. The Campa engineers actually redesigned Brinkmann's adapter, changing the characteristics of an internal spring. This fixed the problem, but Brinkmann was uninterested in incorporating Campa's redesign.

Long story short, I ended up switching to the Partner Steel stove.



This is why I'm a member of this forum! Great information and because of it will most likely return to wal-mart and order the partner steel. By the way how well does the partner steel do on propane useage??


Ben
 

Green Ganesha

Adventurer
benedmonson said:
By the way how well does the partner steel do on propane useage??

I wouldn't be surprised if the Partner Steel stove is relatively propane-greedy, based on its heat output, but an 11- or 20-pound tank lasts a LONG time, no matter what. I can't give you anything quantitative though.
 

grahamfitter

Expedition Leader
These statements should be taken with a pinch of salt because, while I can slice, dice and clean like a pro, when it comes to the art of cooking I'm not worthy. Anyway...

We use a double-burner Century propane stove and a portable gas grill which are hooked up to a 10 Lb bulk propane tank.

View attachment 12344View attachment 12346

The nice thing about the Century stove its cheap, reliable, slim and reasonably easy to clean. The fuel line can be left connected to the bulk propane hose which can also be coiled up inside the stove. The grill works OK - not as well as the larger grill we have at home - but then its only $20. The disadvantage is it doesn't pack smaller and only lasts two seasons before vanishing in a pile of rust. At least no cleaning is required!

I like this setup because it meets the chef's one basic requirement: Grill and cook for four plus people without needing to light a charcoal grill or a camp fire. One fill of propane lasts all summer, too.

However it is rather bulky and I have a Jeep Wrangler so I'd prefer to carry less stuff around without losing any culinary functionality.

One thing I've been idly thinking about is to replace the stove and grill with two double-burner Coleman gasoline stoves with a cast-iron grill pan on one of them.

View attachment 12345View attachment 12347

I think that the whole thing will be significantly smaller than what we've got, even with a can of white gas, and we can use unleaded if that runs out.

However neither of us have ever used a Coleman gas stove before, nor a grill pan. I've read that both are fine for cooking but I've not read of them being used together.

So questions to the many expert chefs here:

  1. Will a grill pan work on a gasoline stove?
  2. What kind of gas mileage do these stoves get?

Or am I barking up the wrong tree?

Cheers,
Graham
 
Last edited:

mountainpete

Spamicus Eliminatus
grahamfitter said:
So questions to the many expert chefs here:

  1. Will a grill pan work on a gasoline stove?
  2. What kind of gas mileage do these stoves get?

Or am I barking up the wrong tree?

Cheers,
Graham

Not an expert chef, although I do have many years of eating experience..:chowtime: .

I regularly use a camp griddle pan with my propane camp stove (have used it with a Coleman white gas model too). In many ways it is my first choice for sunny side up eggs and pancakes. You do have a cooler spot in the middle of the two burners, but it is very managable.

As far as fuel, that really depends on how you cook. On a propane model with two burners on high, it probably lasts for just over an hour. With only one on a very low simmer, I wouldn't be surprised to see over 4 hours. For a white gas model, you would probably get around 90 - 100 minutes with a fullish tank with both burners on high. One burner on slow simmer, around 6 hours.

Pete
 

mountainpete

Spamicus Eliminatus
Just to add Graham... I use that exact setup 90% of the time. 2 burner stove plus a mini BBQ style grill. I do love to indulge in a steak or two while out camping and love using the mini BBQ. It also does wonders on small frozen pizzas.

Pete
 

grahamfitter

Expedition Leader
mountainpete said:
Just to add Graham... I use that exact setup 90% of the time. 2 burner stove plus a mini BBQ style grill. I do love to indulge in a steak or two while out camping and love using the mini BBQ. It also does wonders on small frozen pizzas.

Pete

Thanks for the speedy response, Pete!

It looks like its possible to cook a good steak on a grill pan - with the grooved side up - does this work on a camp stove too? Does it matter that there's no lid to keep the heat in?

Cheers,
Graham
 

mountainpete

Spamicus Eliminatus
grahamfitter said:
Thanks for the speedy response, Pete!

It looks like its possible to cook a good steak on a grill pan - with the grooved side up - does this work on a camp stove too? Does it matter that there's no lid to keep the heat in?

Cheers,
Graham

It will work and I have done it in the past with a two sided , but I'll warn you that it's not going to taste as good as on a true grill. With a BBQ grill you get tasty flareups, etc, that make a steak a steak. You're basically going one step above a frying pan steak that way.

A grooved grill pan does do things like sausages and peppers well though.

Pete
 
Green Ganesha said:
Holy jaw-dropper! Is that a $900+ burner sliding out the back of your truck...?


It is if you pay retail but who does that? :jump: :jump: i didnt pay half that for this one and it was brand new. Im still amazed at how efficient this thing is. I have had it in the back of my truck for 2 years not and still havent used up a 20 pound tank and ive used it for weeks at a time as well as every time i go boarding at lunch time
 

Forum statistics

Threads
188,273
Messages
2,904,760
Members
229,805
Latest member
Chonker LMTV
Top