*Byrd Cara Cara sheepsfoot, serrated rescue knife, clipped to the underside of the lid.  There's a standard gold and brown boot lace that I use as a lanyard on it.  In an emergency, just open the lid and pull the boot lace. 
*Mini MagLite LED or my 20 year old SureFire which has been upgraded to LED.
*Cellphone chargers (there are 2 USB charge ports in there)
*Half inch socket the size of my lug nuts
*Fisher SpacePen Bullet
*Usually toss my gas receipts in there, as if I'm going to really do anything with them.  Every now and then I clear them out
*In the 2nd, lower console, I do keep the lug nut key and sometimes a Volt-Ohm multimeter.  At other times that's in the truck bed in a totem or milk crate