Tacoma's are great trucks but I would go with the 4runner. I had a tacoma DC for about two years. The only real plus side to the truck was I could throw my kayak and bike in the bed and go.Also great 4x4 drive, with the only downside to it being the electronic shift. The interior of the tacoma is small for me, it got a little packed with me a dog and a girlfriend. The bed of the truck is in my opinion a big trunk, not really good for anything besides bikes,kayaks, and luggage. Trying to haul lumber in the bed was funny, the wood would stick out of the to far in my opinion. I now own an FJ, i know not one of your choices but closer to the 4runner. I like the interior room and the 4x4 is the same just with a manual gearbox, which i like better. All i have to do now is throw the kayak on the roof rack and the bike on a hitch mount. thats my two cents, both are good vehicles.