Ok so there is a ton of really good info here, i have read this post prolly 10 times now trying to fully understand, please see my comments/questions written in red below each item. And thanks so much for the detailed analysis!
:smilies27
1. Most battery types don't accept such a high current
There are a lot of different lead acid battery types. Only a few can accept such high currents during charging for a long time. The result is that the voltage goes up very fast to the regulator voltage and then the charge current drops automatically. So even your alternator has 200 A rating it may charge them only with 50 A.
So even a hi amp alternator might only put out 50amps, is this every hour?
2. Regulator voltage is typical to low to sustain high currents
Typical regulator voltage is about 14 V. As a rule of thumb, with this voltage you can expect with a typical battery a current of about 20 % of Ah rating till about 70 % state of charge. If you charge only with 10 % of Ah rating it goes up until about 80 % SOC until the current drops. If you go much higher with charging the 14 V will be reached much earlier. Then the charge current is constantly dropping. If the battery is really empty then it takes much more hours for the battery to become full than you would expect.
3. Voltage drop at high currents will reduce charge current further.
With very high current you get a very high voltage drop at the wiring and the battery poles. This reduces charge voltage even further below 14 V.
4. Typical regulators a temperature compensated and reduce charge voltage
If the the alternator gets hot because of the high current over a long time then the regulator will reduce charge voltage. This will reduce the the current the battery accepts.
5. There are other power consumers that reduce the available current for charging
When using your car there are a lot of other power consumers that are
stealing from available charge current. All your standard appliances like radio, navigation system, lights, air cond., ... and the camper appliances like fridge use all together a lot of power. This can be more than 50 A alone.
So please do not be disappointed when you have changed only to a higher rated alternator and the charging takes to long.
The first thing you should do is to install an intelligent battery computer which shows not only the voltage and the current in and out of the battery, but also the state of charge of the battery. Only if you have information about the current flow and your power usage you can analyse what to do.
Do you have any suggestions for battery computers? Whats is a good one where is a good place to purchase?
Before you upgrade the alternator you should look whether it already delivers the maximum current with a discharged battery. If it uses the maximum current then an upgrade is worthwhile.
Will the battery computer tell me what the alternator is putting out? And how do i know what my alternator is supposed to put out, does it say ON the alternator?
The cheapest way to improve charging is normally in improve the wiring. The loss in the cable can be considerably and additionally the reduced voltage at the battery decreases the current acceptance of the battery.
So would you suggest using wire much bigger than needed? Or just slightly bigger? or just the right size?
The next thing to look is the regulator. There are intellegent regulators or voltage boosters available that do a 3/4-stage charging with higher voltage. But look for one that has an external temperatur sensor at least for the battery. This avoids overcharging the battery which is especially critical if you use a non-flooded GEL or AGM battery. For flooded batteries this is not that critical, but you have to look at the liquid level regularily to avoid drying it out.
I have searched for this thing all over the place, could you tell me where a good place to get one is? And you have any suggested brands to look for?
The best regulators have two additional sensors:
- An additional temperature sensor for the alternator to prevent overheating.
- An voltage sensor for the battery to allow compensation of voltage drop of the wiring.
With such a regulator you get the max out of your alternator and battery combination.
The only thing that may the charging even further is to use batteries with a very high current acceptance like the
http://www.lifelinebatteries.com/ batteries. They can accept a multiple of its Ah rating as current till they are nearly full. But of course, they are very expensive. But be very careful. Without a temperatur sensor at the alternator the alternator may be killed if you have a high capacity installed. If they are nearly empty charging the battery is just like a shortcut.
Im looking at 3 of the group 31's, Lifeline that is
I hope this answers most of the questions. As our motorhome is very dependend on electical energy with high power, I have optimized everything so far that with 1-2 hours drive about one day of energy usage can be charged. The AGM batteries are good for about one week typical usage. As we normally stay only about a maximum of 3-4 days until we move to a new place, we have absolute no energy problem.[/QUOTE]
Again thank you very much for your help, this is pretty complicated stuff for me and your explanaiton helped a lot.
:REExeSwimmingHL: