Hey guys bringing this thread back to life. I am seriously considering this size tire for my '16 frontier. I am currently looking at the grabber or cooper at3 LT. one question though for my spare tire, I currently have a very new cooper stmaxx in 256/75/16 size for my spare. would this be safe to use as my spare or should I be looking at getting 5 tires of the same size?
your 265 spare will be fine.
A few things to consider, because i was in a similar situation to you earlier this year. I have a '17 Frontier.
-I believe all 235/85s are going to be E rated. Heavy tire with a heavy sidewall you really don't need.
-16 sizing really decreases your available options.
-Many C or even P rated tires are available in 265/75 16
I kept looking all around for the best solution and i settled on buying a set of 17" wheels off a Frontier SV and added a set of 255/75 17 BFG KO2s. A pretty light tire setup (the tires are C-rated), wheels weigh almost the same as the stock 16s. Just a suggestion to consider.
If i didn't end up with the 17" wheels, i was going to C-rated 265/75 16s (there aren't many options...). Then again, i had no problems wheeling the stock P-rated AT/Ms. They took the truck all throughout NC/SC/TN and all the big trails in Colorado (Engineer Pass, Black Bear, etc).