I thought I'd report back since I've got a few miles on the new AT3 XLTs. I went with 275/70r18 E-rated tires on a factory stock 2013 F150 FX4, moving away from a 265/70 P-rated street tire. I've got about 3k miles on them now, almost all pavement so far. They are very quiet, even at speed. Like, I can't really tell a difference from the street tires I took off of it except maybe above 70mph. Even then, it might just be wind noise. The ride is great. I can feel slightly more impact over bumps I think, but from the passenger seat my wife says she can't tell any difference at all. I can feel the additional weight of the tires (+20 lbs EACH) in a couple ways. Acceleration is less crisp. I lost a solid 1mpg average, maybe a little more on the highway. And I can feel the stock shocks have to work harder to control repetitive movement like concrete seams. Totally worth these tradeoffs for now, and I can remedy them with a tune and better shocks. Well, not the MPG, but mid 14s around town is fine for a 6700lb truck. I did find that they are happier at 50PSI than the 45 that the store set them to. Better control on road, little accel gain, and I gained 0.2 MPG on average, and the ride didn't change. If they appear to be wearing on the outside edges when I get to the first rotation I may go up a little more. Towing a 2500lb boat around is a non issue.
Off road - I've only done some runs on dry gravel roads but they were fine. They do tend to pick up a LOT of pea gravel. Glad I've got mudflaps to keep the rock bullets off the paint.
So far, so good. I really can't get over how nice they ride and drive on road.