I vote for no body lift as well. Like mentioned already that if you are really tall, you may benefit with the extra leg room but that's about it. If you go with a taller seat height to compensate for the new windshield height, you will now be that much further from the pedals. Short legs won't be happy.
As far a adding rock sliders, you have other choices.
You can cut out your pan halves and replace with thicker material, thus reducing the need for stiffening the pan with a 2" lift. The body itself if structurally sound will be all you need. Baja's are very abuse resistant from the factory, and body flex isn't usually an issue. Sound front and rear torsion tubes, and the back bone down the center are really all that matter to keep the car running true.
Another option would be to add a set of nerf bars. They are easy to install in place of the running boards, and if you plate the bottoms, they will function just fine for rock sliders. You need to remember that your car will be somewhere around 2000 lbs give or take 500 lbs, and you won't need 1.75" tubes anywhere on the car for protection. 1", and 1.5" are traditionally the main tube sizes needed for cage's, bumpers, and nerf bars.
On a baja build it is really easy to over estimate what is needed to have a sturdy, functional car that can take a
serious beating.
Take for example, my '74 Orange bug. Built and drove this car hard for 5 years. It was my weekend forest basher, dune runner, and daily driver all in one.
Factory stock B/J beam with 2.5" lifted spindles that I made, factory stock rear suspension bits with the spring plates moved 1 spline for a 3" lift. Factory stock 4spd transaxle, balanced 1641 DP single 34mm Solex carb. Stock seats and seat belts, and no roll cage.
The car took a beating over and over and over, and never let me down.
I lost count on how many times I jumped the car, but it was ridiculous.
The only upgrades I did to the car was to swap out the front beam with a '74 Thing beam after I landed hard on the drivers side and slightly bent it. Then changed out the transaxle for a '73 bus 3 rib (002) to give a better set of gear ratios, and to run Type 4 CV's.
That's it!
Unfortunately it looks like this now after it was recovered from theft. Sold it and everything I had VW to my buddy to resurrect.