they look good, but it sounds like their under the surface construction isn't any different than their other versions. not enough to get me to ever consider them - sounds like from the initial impressions they suffer from many of the same faults as the originals and won't be any better. BF Goodrich needs to get a grip on themselves. they're losing to Goodyear, General and Nitto/Toyo
Yeah, different folks like different things, which is why all of these "tests" are subjective, of course
. You do raise a good point though, if a person isn't happy with the KO's, these will not be much different as far as on road ride. I think the foul weather handling will be improved, but only time will tell there.
I bought them in the hopes that the under-surface construction, as you put it, WAS exactly the same. The old ones wore well, and are extremely tough off road. I knew the ride was likely not any better, but the new siping and outer lug changes should help in snow/ice as well as in mud, to a degree. They aren't going to be a mud terrain, and will still clog easily, based on my previous experience with this tread design.
I don't think they are losing out, though. They sell A LOT of tires. I think some of the characteristics that are bad for light vehicles, like 4 runners or jeeps, are much less pronounced in large, full sized trucks. In many cases, the E rating is exactly what a guy with a full sized needs or wants. I would have preferred a C, or at most a D, but oh well.
I had the new MTR. It was great off road, much better than these, but wore quickly. They were also a bit worse in the snow, but better, I'm told, than the KM2 in the snow (on road), by a lot. The rest, for me, as I put in the first post, have the sidewall issue. Especially the duratracs. I was really considering trying a duratrac, but many guys in my local club have them, and they have been ripping out sidewalls over and over on trails where other tires have gone through just fine. I'm sure its a mental thing, but currently, I just can't buy a radial tire that doesn't have 3 ply, and even there, with the duratracs, that isn't always enough.