I've had both. I have a Leer right now. It's nice I like it, but for some reason I think the ARE was built better. I've had the Leer on my 2004 GMC Canyon for 6 years, I originally put the ARE on a 1992 S-10. I think you should really take a look at what you want it to do (ie. hold a rack) and make a decision based on that. Those two manufacturers are good, hell they've been battling it out for many years now.