check my reasoning on getting a 4th gen 4Runner

nerd

New member
Hi folks,

I just registered to ask for help here, as it seems this is a good crowd for informed yet balanced advice. I want a new-to-me 4x4. My first-gen Xterra (bought w/ 86k) now has about 190k and has mostly sat still for several years. I rebuilt the top end of the engine myself a couple of years ago to address the head gasket, in part to see if I could do it, and I also did some other work to freshen it up a bit. Before and since, I've held onto it as a tool waiting for a job. I used it heavily until about 2010 as a work vehicle (field biology), then that worked dried up. It has needs: ABS light that might just be dirty sensors or chaffed wiring, parasitic drain that might be the alternator, rusted out rocker panels, rough paint, exhaust on the way out, weepy power steering system, tires at 30%... For a long time I kept saying that the truck was worth more to me than I could get by selling it, so I kept it. I barely use it though, as we've had multiple more reliable and cheaper to run vehicles come and go in the last 8 years. As it sits, it slowly degrades of course. It, like our other two cars, is a tight fit for long trips with the family, big dog, and gear. I could fix it up a bunch more with about $1500 and lots of my time, but...then perhaps if I get pictures up on the Xterra forums and honestly describe the work that's been done and it's remaining needs I might be able to get...$3000? I hope so. My work situation has recently changed for the better, my family is growing, and for both reasons I'm short on time. I think it's worth getting a smallish loan to pick up a newer ride, and also sell the Xterra and another of our 3 current vehicles to put toward that purchase. I figure that going down to two vehicles makes sense for us financially and otherwise right now (and would free up room for me to get an older Miata or MR2 in a couple of years!).

I want something that 1) will reliably and comfortably eat highway miles and then function well on the forest service roads, logging areas, farm fields, and swampy territory that my work takes me to, and where I can't afford breakdowns, 2) can comfortably haul my whole family on our adventures for the next 8-10 years or so, and 3) serve as a foul weather country commuter. I think that a low miles 2005-2009 4Runner would fit the bill. I'm interested in finding one with the V6/multimode/timing chain, but I have yet to even sit in any 4th gen. Next week I will check out a nearby 2007 V8 Sport with 76k with some flashy mods (but supposedly never been offroad, priced way over KBB). The only other vehicles I've seriously considered are the 2nd gen Xterra (not much bigger than our current vehicles, not as comfortable onroad, not Toyota quality) and maybe a Pathfinder (meh). Much less rational options would be FZJ80, GX450/470, V6 Cayenne, and other options to far into the luxury/high operative cost side.

As I pursue this, I'd like reassurances from early 4th gen owners that these vehicles are reliable well into their second decade and won't turn to oxide at the first sign of winter on the edge of the rust belt. We'd probably put 10k or less a year on it, so if I hold out for one with less than 100k I'd probably be looking to unload it as it approached 200k but more critically, it would probably be over 15 years old before I sell. I'd appreciate any pointers. I know to find out about the timing belt on V8s and to check for operation of the drive modes. Anything else? Thanks and sorry for the long thinking-it-through as I write.
 

Dalko43

Explorer
The 4th gen 4runner is an all-around great vehicle.

My only real complaints with it: it's stock ground clearance and approach angles were nothing special. They weren't horrible, but they could definitely benefit from a small lift (if you are inclined to take it on very rough roads/terrain).

Reliability wise, the truck has done well. It's at about 140k miles and there have been no engine issues (V6). There have been a few things with suspension and brakes that we've had to address, but that has been mostly normal wear and tear.

The V6 is surprisingly torquey when you step on the pedal. While the V8 4runner has always appealed to me, the V6 is more than sufficient for most uses, and you get slightly better mpg. I would only consider the V8 if you planned on hauling/towing a lot of stuff, very big tires, or you just liked the extra horsepower that much more.

The interior is nice and comfortable; it's not a lexus-grade interior, but it works well enough for long road trips.

As for rust, well if you live in the northeast, you're going to get rust, that's just a given. I have yet to do a thorough cleaning of the truck, but I have been underneath it a few times. There is definitely more rust on it than what you would see from a dry state. So far, I don't see the rust really degrading any of the structure or parts. I do plan on scraping off some of the rust and applying fluid film sometime next year. I would definitely advise trying to buy this truck from a southern or arid state; it will save you a lot of hassle in the long run.


As for your options, I guess it comes down to what you want/need. The stock 4th gen 4runner is plenty capable in most situations. If you desire, you can add mods to it to make it even more capable (front/rear diff lockers, front bumper, winch); it's a great platform to modify.

I've heard good things about the 2nd gen Xterra (which has about the same torque but slightly more hp). However, I've also heard of reliability issues with it (certain years had transmission fluid leaks, rear leaf springs sagging, front diff breaking during hard offroading).

You could look at crossovers like the Jeep Grand Cherokee or Cherokee, Subaru outback....you'll get better mpg and ride comfort but with the obvious caveat that they are unibody, not Body on Frame, vehicles. Depending on how rough of terrain you plan on driving, those could work as well.
 

djtc

Adventurer
I've had several toyota trucks and while the others were better in some areas , the 4th gen is a better truck all around. Comfort, fuel mileage,power, space ,offroad capability are all things the 4th gen has. I just spent a month on the road with mine going through some technical terrain and it never skipped a beat.
 

CA-RJ

Expo Approved™
Your requirements in a vehicle are identical to mine. I have been daily driving a 91 Land Cruiser on 35's for the last 4 years and had finally decided it was time for something more civilized. Enter the 4th get 4runner. I just bought my 2004 V6 last week but love it. I'd never sat in one before, but still knew that's what I wanted. I describe it as a car with low range. Comfortable? Oh yeah. Plenty of room in the back for the kids (mine are still in car seats and those suckers take up some space!). Ride is very nice and pretty quiet. The whole vehicle feels sturdy and well put together. I do a lot of farm road driving and this will serve as our winter vehicle as well. Our has 135k miles and looking at the service history for it, it's had nothing but regular maintenance. My buddy has a 2003 with 244k and his is the same story.

If you need more ground clearance, there are tons of options available. For the type of off-road conditions you're describing, I wouldn't think you'd really need much lift, if any. There are plenty off AT tires available in the stock tire size and if you put a leveling spacer in front I think a 265/70-17 would fit (which opens up even more tire choices).

4th Gen prices are kinda all over the place. If you can afford it, the 05+ are nice because you get the 5 speed transmission. The V8 also got VVTi and a horsepower increase as well. For reference, I picked mine up from a Lexus dealership in pristine condition for $10,500.
 

94toy22re

Observer
I just purchases a 2007 Sport V8 AWD in July after selling my 94 Toyota pickup. Paid 14k and it had 123k. I have been loving the power and comfort compared to the pickup. I love always being in 4 wheel drive, i don't know if i could ever go back the regular part time system.
 

C-grunt

New member
I got a buddy with a 2007 V8 with somewhere around 160k miles and the only thing outside of regular maintenance he has replaced was a window switch. Another buddy of mine's roommate recently sold his 2007 V8 with 180k miles that still ran like a champ. He only sold it to buy a Tundra. Both guys give the 4th gen very high praise for its comfort, cargo room, reliabilty, and off road abilities.
 

bh9

New member
I moved from a 1st gen xterra to a 4th gen T4R. The two aren't even comparable. My T4R is a modern, comfortable truck with plenty of off-road capability for my needs. The xterra was an old beater. They had similar mileage...

I bought the 4th gen because I wanted something newer than a 3rd gen, cheaper than a 100 series, and better on the highway than an 80 series. While it is less popular than those other options, it shares a chassis and suspension with the FJ Cruiser so aftermarket support is there. I use it as a daily driver / camping rig that is very capable, rather than as an offroading rig that I can drive to work if I need to.

I got the V8, but only because I over-reacted to my underpowered, undergeared xterra on 33"s. Even on 35"s, with full armor and tons more weight, the regeared V8 accelerates like a normal car. I'm not as big of a fan of the electronic transfer case in the T4R as the manual one in the xterra.

The interior is worlds apart. Modern automatic climate control, nice stereo etc vs an end-of-life Frontier interior from the 90s. The T4R feels a bit bigger inside. I've slept in both many times, and the T4R seems to be a bit longer. The rear seat cushions don't have to be removed to fold flat like the Xterra's do. I don't like how much more the wheel wells protrude into the passenger compartment, but without that I probably wouldn't fit 35"s, so it's a compromise. Lots of thought clearly went into the T4R's interior, like the adjustable size cupholders (with lights!), or the burger tray, or the light in the glovebox, or the trash bag holder... The xterra was very simple.

The difference hit me one day while I was browsing through the FSM for a schematic on the climate control system- The T4R has a "sunlight detector" on the dash (I think to increase the cooling if its bright outside), an interior temp sensor and all the other complex electronics to go with auto climate control. The xterra had a knob, with one side blue, and the other red. The T4R has a yaw rate sensor that people talk about having to recalibrate. The T4R has TPMS. ATRAC. Stability Control. On and on...

I can't compare how they drive because the xterra was badly lifted 6" and on M/Ts, vs the T4R on quality suspension and lift with much better A/Ts. Worlds apart, but I paid for it.

Guess which one I like better? Guess which one I'd rather try to debug and fix? Though I've found much, much more online support for the T4R than the xterra. If I have a problem, a few minutes of online searching and I'll find a forum post where someone else did the same thing. That wasn't nearly as true of the xterra. I never really considered how useful that is until I moved from a Nissan to a Toyota. And the 4th gen is probably the least popular of the Toyota choices! Helping a friend work on a 90s Jeep blew me away with the information out there.

Make sure to check ALL the switches and knobs on such an electronic vehicle. Not that you expect them to go wrong, but just to not get a lemon. Make sure the 4LO and Center Diff Lock work (read up how to do engage them before going car shopping). Almost every single center console backlight in mine was burned out when I bought it with 140k, but I was able to find and replace them all (by tearing the dash apart).

If you are considering the 4th gen, you should also consider the FJC and GX470. The FJ has an interior better suited to camping and offroading (less carpet) but with less room, and the GX470 has a higher roofline and side swing rear door.

As far as a family camping and road trip rig, I think the 4th gen is perfect. Add bigger tires and lift as desired for capability, and enjoy.
 
Last edited:

nerd

New member
Wow, what a response! Thanks for all the intel.

Plans changed and I actually went to check out the local truck yesterday. Guy is asking $200 over NADA clean retail for a V8 Sport with 75000 miles, "cuz all the work I've done to it". That work includes murdered out tint, taillights, headlights, and trim, big black wheels with new MT tires, "bangin stereo" with amp and sub, alarm system and remote starter, etc. The first thing I did was crawl underneath. The Flowmaster exhaust is rusty but doesn't leak. The suspension in front and rear show quite a lot of rust and the frame has more surface corrosion than I'd like. And here's the kicker: he claimed the truck has never been offroaded but the OEM skid plate under the gas tank (?) is bashed in and has rusted over scratches on it. Everything worked, but as soon as I saw the underside I knew that the engine, interior, and test drive were just for practice and I wouldn't be buying this one.
 

Martinjmpr

Wiffleball Batter
I would ignore KBB if I were you. Depending on where you live, KBB is often very low, simply because the market for used vehicles (especially 4runners) is pretty hot.
.
Here in Denver at least you won't find anybody selling near KBB or Edmund's value unless it's in bad shape.
 

nerd

New member
The seller of the 2007 was texting me all afternoon and had a hard time understanding why I was no longer interested. It was not in "excellent condition, needs nothing" as listed. It came from North Dakota and Washington before that and he is the second owner. Local dealer posted a 2005 SR5 V6 with even less miles for $1500 less today, and I'm waiting on more photos after they recondition it. I suspect that NADA is a good judge of dealer prices in my area, at least from comparing online listings with the NADA prices. I think this market is relatively low for these vehicles. This isn't Denver.
 

Scat Adams

Observer
I would seriously give the GX470 a real hard look. I bought my '05 (vvti V8) for the same price as I would've paid for a similarly equipped 4th gen T4r. Plus you get all the extra goodies with the Lexus, the GX470 really reminds me of a smaller 100 series. Another plus is that a lot of GX's were soccer mom owned and usually have been well kept. Good luck!
 

2025 deleted member

Well-known member
The seller of the 2007 was texting me all afternoon and had a hard time understanding why I was no longer interested. It was not in "excellent condition, needs nothing" as listed. It came from North Dakota and Washington before that and he is the second owner. Local dealer posted a 2005 SR5 V6 with even less miles for $1500 less today, and I'm waiting on more photos after they recondition it. I suspect that NADA is a good judge of dealer prices in my area, at least from comparing online listings with the NADA prices. I think this market is relatively low for these vehicles. This isn't Denver.

Stuff in Oklahoma is selling higher than book values also. Quite a bit for a lot of Toyota 4x's
 

Forum statistics

Threads
188,476
Messages
2,905,616
Members
230,428
Latest member
jacob_lashell
Top