upcruiser
Perpetual Transient
The other factor is why buy new? If the 9yr old used trucks that are 3/4 the price of a new on get the same mileage?
My Subaru gets 23-24mpg around town, no trailer or bikes up top we typically see 28-31 on road trips and with our camp trailer 21-22 add bikes up too we get knocked to 18mpg. The new Canyon is pretty close on interior quality to the Subaru and yes the diesel bests the Subaru on mileage. Add that the truck gains 4x4 capability over the Subaru has better load hauling ability. Etc etc. it's a very attractive replacement option.
We just did 2700 mile trip in our Sequoia 4.7L towing our 4x6. 16mpg average across NV and ID, 20-21mpg Around YellowStone / Grand Tetons and 15mpg on the way home against a head wind. Only reason we took the Sequoia was I could pack all our gear easily into the back of the truck vs bins on the trailer I would have had to remove at two hotel stays. A diesel Canyon would have easily done 30mpg + on that trip and accommodated gear under a locked cap.
The main reason we went new was primarily the safety aspect. My wife driving our two kiddos around in the winter up here in the Upper Peninsula, an old Outback was going to be a losing proposition in 90% of the vehicles that could be involved since everyone drives full size trucks. We also got 10k off the retail so it was hard to pass up and supporting a company that brought a mid size diesel to the states was in my eyes worthwhile.