I'm surprised that nobody has mentioned Goodyear Duratracs yet.
Those of you with the Coopers - I'm reading that a few folks have complained about premature tire wear and noise. Any feedback?
I've been a BFG guy all my life for DD, but they are demanding a premium for their name these days, so looking for alternatives for the wife's 2014 4Runner. Hopefully one that doesn't kill mileage (she has dealer installed Michelins now - they are cracking after < 3 years, but get great mileage).
As I said above, I'm at 44K on my AT3s and wish they would wear out - I want some new ones, but they probably have 10,000 or 15,000 miles left in them (they have a 55K mile warranty). I measured the tread and it is exactly 1/4" left. I do hear them a little but not anything like a mud tire - somebody goes by me with those and I definitely know it. They are very smooth and pretty quiet.
Out of curiosity, what load rating are you running? I typically run load range C, but thinking the SL for the 4runner based on cost and trying to keep her in a slightly smoother ride.
Sorry if I missed it, but is there an option for a 2nd set of wheels? If daily driving/MPG is a concern, I would personally get some 30" highway all-seasons on 15" rims for daily driving duties for max on-road performance and MPG gains, then more aggressive set for your offroad ventures.
If that's not an option, I have personally enjoyed BFG KO's. They're do well in all types of terrain and last a long time. After about 50% tread, performance decreases dramatically, so I usually end up selling them for $200-300 and buy new ones. Size wise, forget 235/85/16. I noticed no MPG gains (about 19mpg with either tire) and on and offroad performance decreased compared to 265/75/16. These just have no lateral grip, which can be unnerving especially off road. There is NO advantage of the 235's over 265's other than possibly price.