p nut
butter
Another thing is, many people buy their vehicle, get it paid off, then want to keep it as long as possible. It would be horrible to HAVE to get rid of it, and only get reimbursed for a small portion of it's actual day to day value for the owner. $5000 wont even buy a good used car these days. Once again, the consumer looses. If they offered me $5000 for my car (150,000+ miles) or truck, I'd say forget it, it's worth way more than that to me.
The VW owners are getting KBB value + $5k (according to the other poster. I haven't verified). There would be an upheaval if TDI owners only got back $5k. That's equivalent of an oil change on those cars.