If I totaled my truck I'd get another 89-91 XtraCab with the only change being a V6 instead of the 22R-E. Easier to swap to the 3.4L, which is the one and only thing better about the Taco. Nothing I've seen or driven has floated my boat including the 70 series ute (yes, you heard that right), 40, 60, 80, various 4Runners and a Tacoma. That one's too big, this one's too small, blah, blah. The truck I have now with a 5VZ and functioning A/C would be exactly the right truck.
Ranchero, could that be licensed in Colorado with the changes to the collector car laws? Not sure how the emissions stuff would work out since the 3L-TE didn't come here. Might be able to use a 2L, although you run into the swap must be your model year or newer issue maybe.