That would be amazing.
I am guessing that first gear in the six speed tranny is much lower than our stock first gear. That alone would make it worth it.
The too tall gearing of first and reverse are a constant source of frustration off road for me
That is a big part of my motivation. I've got 3.42s in the diff, live in the mountains, and drive my van with a light offroad trailers to way out there camping spots. I have had whole offroad clubs an a ride stop to ask me "******?" deep in the canyons of Utah.
I was originally looking at a transfer case swap to get 4lo, but didn't want to lose AWD as my wife regularly drives the van on snowy and icy roads half the year. Given how capable and reliable our AWD is compared to anything that would swap in, losing the seamless OEM function, the increased risk to the pretty weak 7.2" front diff, and the fact that I need a transmission got me thinking.
Re-gearing the diffs to 4.11 on 265/75r16 tires will bring the final ratio just a smidge lower than factory 3.73s and 245/75r16's. (1st and OD, 12.58 and 2.88, 11.41 and 2.61 respectively) With the 4l60 this should help to compensate for the load and location of my van without compromising too much on economy (and might even help).
In my current setup (stock with 3.42s) final drive in first, OD and reverse are 10.47, 2.39 and 7.83 respectively. The problems I have with this setup is it is slow off the line, hunts gears constantly, has to downshift to third and scream to get up any incline at speed, sometimes requires a questionable amount of momentum offroad to avoid stalling out the converter and the brakes get a workout when descending anything at low speed.
With a NP242 and current gearing 4lo in 1st and reverse would be 28.36 and 21.22 respectively. Advantages here besides the obvious lower gearing offroad is the ability to use 2lo and keep moving if you break something in the front drivetrain. I am using the NP242 because it is the best option for a manual shift TC that still has a decent Fulltime 4wd mode. Down side is there is no great place in my van for the shifter that wouldn't be in the way and get constantly bumped by dogs, kids, or feet, it requires more thought from the driver, and I'm not sure how the FT4WD would perform and hold up under constant winter use under such a heavy load. Realistically these vans will never be rock crawlers and 4lo is likely overkill, at least for me.
With a 6l80 and 4.11s 1st, OD and reverse would be 16.56, 2.75 and 12.58 respectively with a lot more choices in between. For what I do with my van this combo would get me pretty close to 4lo type of performance with out the complexity for use as a daily, and will likely result in better fuel economy as well. A key function to this working well offroad is the ability to use the 6l80's manual mode to lock into the gear you need, and is one of the more interesting part of the conversion to figure out and keep everything looking OEM.
Right now I am stuck trying to figure out if there is an off the shelf adapter out there that will work to get the BW4473 on to the 6l80 without having to get a custom input shaft built for the TC. Most of the 4wd 6l80 swap stuff available is for Jeep L(X) swaps and involve replacing the input shaft on a Jeep TC for a 32 spline input.