It depends SO MUCH on your weight and application!
I had now 2x Toyo MT 285/75R16 on our 3.6-3.8ton overland Toyota HZJ75 vehicle. Still traveling, right now in Bolivia and going to buy the Hankook's MT because I don't trust the BFG MT and there are no TOYO's in this size here.
Anyway, I had 8 flats so far, all bolts & nails, I guess every tire would have had a puncture. Sidewalls are really strong. BUT we got of BOTH sets only about 25'000miles out of them and they are completely gone! On 2 tires chunks are missing and I see the nylon plies! So they have to go!
Mud performance I can't compare to others, but we got stuck often in mud with our weight and the Toyo MT. Means it didn't convince me. Will next week go through the Amazon and lots of mud and will see how the Hankook Dynapro MT perform.
Noise is great on the TOYO MT. Less noise than on the BFG AT!
My 2 cents.