Where the Rubber Meets the Road
If you haven't made your purchase yet, there is an article you should check out. It sounds like you have kind of settled on an all terrain. There was an article on Expo Portal, "Where the Rubber Meets the Road" I believe. It went through a number of tests on a number of the most popular all terrain tires. I would recommend reading that, it was very well done. It may help you in your decision. All though I will say that it does not include the BFG KO2's as they weren't out yet when the testing for this article was done, but they do go through it with the BFG KO's. I recently went through your same dilemma and ended up deciding between the Cooper AT3's, Falken Wild Peaks, and the BFG KO2's and chose the Cooper AT3's. It didn't hurt that the KO2's cost 33% more than the Cooper's when I bought them.
If you haven't made your purchase yet, there is an article you should check out. It sounds like you have kind of settled on an all terrain. There was an article on Expo Portal, "Where the Rubber Meets the Road" I believe. It went through a number of tests on a number of the most popular all terrain tires. I would recommend reading that, it was very well done. It may help you in your decision. All though I will say that it does not include the BFG KO2's as they weren't out yet when the testing for this article was done, but they do go through it with the BFG KO's. I recently went through your same dilemma and ended up deciding between the Cooper AT3's, Falken Wild Peaks, and the BFG KO2's and chose the Cooper AT3's. It didn't hurt that the KO2's cost 33% more than the Cooper's when I bought them.