Honestly I don't begrudge anyone for how they spend their money or free time, more power to you.
Y'all sound like a bunch of little old ladies. Condemning littering, vandalism, not "treading lightly" are all things that should be addressed in the right way. Educating, not scolding or shaming, will have a better chance at changing behavior.
While I agree that it would have been better to raise the people in question with a little more outdoor education (and general manners)...I imagine that these people are "grownups" now. A little late for responsible parenting.
I will endorse and expound on what these 3 gents are saying. From my perspective the “I resent people trying to come enjoy the thing I am passionate about, talk about all the time and advocate for since they are doing it wrong” resembles statements in pop culture such as “I liked XYZ band so much better before they sold out.”
Now are trends like this where a hobby\sport\lifestyle explodes in popularity cyclical in nature and at at their height do they tend to attract people who could fairly be described as poseurs? Absolutely!
However, even with the foreseeable loss of the “fairweather fans” that will move to the next shiny thing such as the folks that previously were all in on the Tiger Woods Golfers\Harley\Import Car Tuner fads will the community overall still be larger afterwards? I would say more than likely.
So where does that leave us? While I admit, it is definitely easier to write people off who are new to the community that we may think are not “doing it right.” I personally can’t advocate for that approach because when I try to put myself in their shoes and try to divine their intent, I quickly realize what some of their motivations may be. For me, it all boils down to the one thing I think is simultaneously the single greatest strength of overlanding, which also happens to be what so many people in the world today are searching for. Even if they don’t realize it or can’t quite define it, the absence of this thing is the root cause of the FOMO phenomenon.
That critical thing is community, specifically the real and authentic kind that can’t be found sharing one’s #bestlife on Instagram or with witty 140 or even supersized 280 character quips. These seekers willing to truly make a deep dive into our culture and kneel at the altar of Overlanding, will come to see that life is best lived far beyond the borders of the 5 to 13” screen they devote so many of their wakened hours to. Out in that margin things can be hard, sweaty, probably dusty or muddy and often a little smelly but those new sensory experiences when shared are the types of things that truly meaningful bonds are made of.
Once they come to that precipice, if we can move out of our comfort zones and try to cross the aisle to offer help or advice when needed (perhaps even be a sort of mentor if the opportunity presents itself) then we can be part of showing new enthusiasts the “right way.” Then not only do we gain more devotees sharing in the pursuit of what we are all so passionate about, we might even help the world out by adding a few more well-rounded other-centered people in the process. If that alone is not a compelling enough reason to be positive about including more off-road]overlanding disciples. Then I would mention that with a larger demand for products used in these activities we will all Iikely benefit from more innovation and economies of scale effect on those item’s pricing.