Need vehicle suggestions for around $3000

What should I get?

  • Jeep Cherokee XJ

    Votes: 56 38.1%
  • Izuzu Trooper

    Votes: 25 17.0%
  • Toyota 4Runner

    Votes: 28 19.0%
  • Discover I

    Votes: 17 11.6%
  • Something else

    Votes: 21 14.3%

  • Total voters
    147

reece146

Automotive Artist
All years of XJ use an Aisin automatic transmission also. ZJs and WJS use craptastic Chryco auto transmissions.
 

RealJon

Member
Since I'm such a 5-speed nut, how likely is it to find a 2000ish Montero (non sport) or Trooper with a 5-speed? What are the lifespans of the automatic transmissions on these? I've personally had bad luck with auto vehicles, the few I've owned started slipping and leaking around 180k.

Also, my budget has increased to closer to $5000 for purchase, which opens things up quite a bit. I'd like to try to get a 2000ish+ vehicle for safety reasons and such (wife was complaining about hauling our future children in an older vehicle with lesser safety features). Can't find a 5-speed on any of the rigs I've been looking for (within a reasonable distance) so I'll probably be settling for an auto.

The Trooper has the 4l30E tranny. I personally have never had issue with the tranny itself but that is because previous owners had taken care of it. I looked for an auto because it offers the TOD option which I did like. You have to be very careful with the trannys and make sure they are in good working condition. At 5k you have alot of options, I would still suggest the Trooper because they can be had for 3000 Easy (Im selling mine at 2500), 500 for the OME Lift, Tires, and the rest on General Maintenance and you are set! This is the build that sold me on the Trooper over a monty. (Plus I liked how I felt in it)
http://www.expeditionswest.com/vehicles/ewvehicles/Isuzu_Trooper/index.html
Remember always check out www.Planetisuzoo.com for any isuzu questions and info!
 

scrubber3

Not really here
The Trooper is definitely a top notch rig. I saw that it and the Montero we very closely matched, but what got me on the Montero was the 9.5inch ring gear and 4.62 factory gear ratio. Plus they can be had with an air locker from the factory. I got the LS which didn't come with one stock, but I installed one out of an SR. Very easy and didn't cost squat. I wouldn't hesitate to get a well taken care of trooper though. Check out my build thread if you wanna know more.
 

PirateMcGee

Expedition Leader
for 5k my vote is a montero sr, 5k should get you into a one in great shape with money still left over for baselining and maybe even some tires/mods. I think they're the best value "expo" vehicle around. Plus they have decent power and mpg's.
 

RealJon

Member
The Trooper is definitely a top notch rig. I saw that it and the Montero we very closely matched, but what got me on the Montero was the 9.5inch ring gear and 4.62 factory gear ratio. Plus they can be had with an air locker from the factory. I got the LS which didn't come with one stock, but I installed one out of an SR. Very easy and didn't cost squat. I wouldn't hesitate to get a well taken care of trooper though. Check out my build thread if you wanna know more.

Yeah we get 4.30 gears and a G80! I just didnt like the look of the monty or the interior feel.

To anyone looking for a vehicle, as you can see we ALL love our vehicles of choice. Find something you are comfortable with and want to travel in and go explore!

Trooper Owners, Monty Owners, we all the same inside !
 
Last edited:

reece146

Automotive Artist
Since your budget has gone up a little... if I was looking today my "complete" short list would include:

Xterra
FZJ80/LX450
UZJ100/LX470
Discovery II (I'm a masochist)
Range Rover Classic (solid trucks)
Fourrunner (2nd - 3rd gen - but I personally don't fit)
Montero
Trooper
LR3 (see Disco above)
full size Grand Wagoneer that's already been gone through "just because"
Various "baby" Jeeps
Ford Explorer

I'm seriously considering importing a GU/Y61 Nissan Patrol but the configuration I want doesn't seem to exist in LHD so I may fall back to one of the above (LX470 or Xterra likely) out of convenience for a turn-key truck. If only they were solid front axle rigs. I don't want to go down the conversion road yet again.

I love my XJ - it's the right size for wheeling and dealing with my family of four. The drivetrain is great, especially after the modifications I've made to the axles but the "Chryslerness" of the interior constantly pisses me off and I'm going to have to do some work to bring it up to my expectations going forward (sound deadening, address fit/shim, even more unibody stiffening).

The WJ is a bit better - at least the unibody is stiff enough out of the box (thanks Porsche!) but it still has a craptastic Chrysler interior. I almost bought one last fall for a winter vehicle but ended up with another XJ just out of a sense of... well... contempt/familiarity/value I guess.

That being said, I like being able to stop at a local store for most parts and being able to get them off the shelf for not a lot of money. It's borderline ridiculous compared to some vehicles.

Consider the safety aspects. To me front air bags on both sides of the vehicle are mandatory.

Also, fuel injection is mandatory.

After those two things the less electronics the vehicle has then the better (later Land Rovers can be a PITA because of that).

Some of the vehicles above don't match these criteria.

Also, keep in mind that old vehicles are just that: old.

 

BigSwede

The Credible Hulk
There are a few 98+ 5-speed Troopers out there, but they are somewhat rare. It is a nice combo from all those who have driven one. And they have a conventional transfer case, not the TOD t-case.
 

chilliwak

Expedition Leader
Get yourself an old 70s or 80s Chevy 4by4 pickup. It will probably only cost you $1000 bucks and you can repair it yourself.:ylsmoke:
 

brianf408

Observer
Since your budget has gone up a little... if I was looking today my "complete" short list would include:

Xterra
FZJ80/LX450
UZJ100/LX470
Discovery II (I'm a masochist)
Range Rover Classic (solid trucks)
Fourrunner (2nd - 3rd gen - but I personally don't fit)
Montero
Trooper

LR3 (see Disco above)
full size Grand Wagoneer that's already been gone through "just because"
Various "baby" Jeeps
Ford Explorer

...

That being said, I like being able to stop at a local store for most parts and being able to get them off the shelf for not a lot of money. It's borderline ridiculous compared to some vehicles.

Consider the safety aspects. To me front air bags on both sides of the vehicle are mandatory.

Also, fuel injection is mandatory.


...

You absolutely hit the nail on the head on what I'm looking for. Definitely want something with both front airbags, decent safety ratings, and fuel injection. Any vehicle that I'm going to drive on a daily basis needs to be fuel injected.

Planning on looking at these in the next few days, to try to get a feel for each of them:
http://kansascity.craigslist.org/cto/2870035362.html
http://kansascity.craigslist.org/ctd/2873289857.html
http://kansascity.craigslist.org/cto/2874801746.html

Are the Land Rovers really that unreliable? There's a pretty sweet Disco II that just showed up in my neighborhood that I drool over every day. I used to be a mechanic so I'm not opposed to working on problems, but I don't want to be constantly wrenching on it just to keep it on the road. I've been pretty spoiled for Japanese reliability with most of my previous vehicles.

Also saw a coworker selling an Xterra, it was a little rough so I thought he'd be selling a deal. Wants near $10k for it, and it's only a 2wd!
 

reece146

Automotive Artist
If you can spin your own wrenches the Disco may not be that bad. I think a lot of the problems with them may be overstated but that said they have really low resale values for a reason. When they go wrong they really go wrong. FWIW, I think they were priced stupidly as a "prestige" vehicle when new and it just isn't. Stupid North American market BS.

I've on and off been looking at them with the thought that if the engine craps the bed I'd swap in a GM LS of some flavour... but the amount of messing around with electronics to get it fully integrated makes it more or a pipe dream than anything - I just don't have that kind of time.

Your co-worker with the Xterra must be dreaming in technicolour unless it is only a few years old or something.

Take a look at the 100 series Land Cruisers above as well. Once you drive one you might want to stretch your budget to make it fit. I think with decent amount of shopping you might be able to find one around $10k. It's the kind of vehicle you only have to buy once. I think they are kind of fugly but adding an ARB bar on the front takes care of that.

At this point it sounds like you've done enough mental gymnastics. Go drive stuff, even the stuff you have mentally side-lined. Some times you get really impressed with a vehicle as a whole instead of just looking at in on paper.
 

reece146

Automotive Artist
Btw, there is a diesel Liberty (05 to 07?) if you are into that. They are over priced on the open market it seems though. Jeeps aren't worth the premium.
 

brianf408

Observer
I've considered the diesel Liberty, and you're exactly right they go for a lot more than I think they're worth. I really wish we had more diesel options in small trucks/SUVs here in the states.

The Xterra my coworker is selling is pretty overpriced. It's an 03 supercharged 2wd, with flat bald tires, faded paint, headliner hanging down, absolutely trashed inside. He can't figure out why in over a month of having it for sale he hasn't had any interest.

At this point you're exactly right, I just need to get out and drive everything I can. Hopefully a few test drives this weekend will help point me in a more certain direction. Thanks for everyone's input so far!
 

reece146

Automotive Artist
FWIW, I would never buy a truck that requires high octane fuel (e.g. supercharged Xterra). It's a pointless extra expense unless the engine was designed to run on low and high without issues.
 

PirateMcGee

Expedition Leader
might as well throw a montero sport into the mix too (look for one with a 3.5L...not that the 3.0 is bad, just mo powa)
 

scrubber3

Not really here
The Xterra my coworker is selling is pretty overpriced. It's an 03 supercharged 2wd, with flat bald tires, faded paint, headliner hanging down, absolutely trashed inside. He can't figure out why in over a month of having it for sale he hasn't had any interest.

In 2006 I bought a 2002 Xterra 4wd for less than 10,000 bucks. It had new tires and only 60,000 miles. In all honesty your friend has what no one wants. I.e. the supercharged version(due to head/intake issues and premium fuel), a 2wd(nuff said), not to mention that it's in bad shape. He'd be lucky to get 4 grand out of that example. That's only if he finds a sucker... We need a first name for this guy, so we can have a reference point for people wanting too much for there vehicle.. Example- if his name was Rick it would go like this..... "wow, look at that beat up escalade, he put chrome 24s on it with some neon lights... 180,000 miles and he wants how much for it? What a RICK!"

It looks like most that have voted want you to get an XJ. :coffeedrink:
 
Last edited:

Forum statistics

Threads
189,789
Messages
2,920,878
Members
232,931
Latest member
Northandfree
Top