Martinjmpr
Wiffleball Batter
So let me start off by saying that my electrical knowledge is rudimentary, at best. Yes, I do have my HAM license and you have to know some stuff (Ohm's law, etc) but I'm banging my head here trying to figure this out.
OK, so let me start off with my issue:
Last year, following the DE-II in Moab, I decided I needed to get a fridge. I got a small one, a Dometic (Waeco) CF-18, which is a 19 liter fridge. My thought then was that the fridge would have stuff that I needed to keep cold (cheese, milk, meat) and that anything where cold was "nice but not necessary" (water, beer, soda) could go in a cooler.
That system worked out pretty well, however, I have had some "issues" with my Dometic fridge. Not that there's anything wrong with it, necessarily, just that it has some quirky features that I need to find a way to work with.
Here are the symptoms that have manifested themselves:
1. Plug the fridge into the 12v aux power socket near the tailgate of my 4runner (NOTE: Earlier this year I did the "jumper" modification to keep the 12v aux outlets powered all the time, so this gets power even when the ignition is off.) The 4runner has been parked for several days at this point (it's not my DD.) I put a bottle of warm water in the fridge to see how well it would cool overnight. Green light comes on (compressor on) but I'm also getting an intermittent red "error" light flashing (see below for description of this from the Waeco web site.)
2. Next morning, come out and check the bottle. Although the green light is on (with the intermittently flashing red "error" light), the bottle is warm.
3. Leaving everything connected, start the truck. Spend about 10 minutes with engine running hooking up the trailer. Drive trailer to trailer repair place to have some welding done. Turn off truck for about 10 minutes. After dropping off trailer, start truck up and drive to work, approximately 13 miles, maybe 25 minutes total. Turn off truck. Fridge is still plugged in to the REAR power outlet with error light intermittently flashing.
4. 11am: Come out to the truck to check the water bottle. It's nice and cold. Still having error light flashing, but it seems to be cooling OK. Incidentally, this has also been my experience on DE-III and on our recent camping trip to Canon City last weekend: Even if the error light is flashing, if the truck is running the fridge will work fine.
5. I also have a 12v plug with alligator clips that I can attach directly to the battery (bypassing the wiring.) I used this on DE-III. Usually when I had this connected to the battery, I got a solid green light with no flashing "error" light (although I did, sometimes, get the flashing error light, sometimes not. Typically if the truck is runnning or has been running for a while, the light is solid green. If the truck has been turned off for a while, the light is green with the intermittently flashing error light.)
6. Just to see if maybe the problem was the wiring to the REAR 12v outlet, last night I connected the fridge to the FRONT 12v outlet. The truck had actually been turned off for some time and yet, I got a green light with no “error” light flashing. Put the water bottle in and left it overnight. Next morning, checked it. Fridge cold, red “error” light flashing, and bottle so cold it had actually partially frozen!
Now, the above is the description of what is happening. Here's my theory on what is going on.
I don't know about the ARB, Engel, Norcold or other fridges, but one feature of the Dometic/Waeco fridges is the automatic cut off that is designed to prevent the battery from being discharged. Depending on the setting, it will cut power to the fridge when it detects a power drop, again this is to preserve the battery.
The web site for the Dometic/Waeco fridges says this:
Regarding the intermittently flashing red error light, the FAQ says:
The FAQ goes on to elaborate that
SO, what I think is happening is this: When the engine of the truck is running[/B (and the alternator is being powered) the voltage is high enough to keep the fridge running even through the wiring that goes back to the 12v aux plug in the back of the truck. When I shut the engine off, there is still enough power to run it, but this power diminishes over time and if I leave the truck off long enough (like when I had the truck parked for 4 days without running it), it produces insufficient voltage, which the low-voltage detector in the fridge "sees" and this prevents the fridge from working.
Furthermore, my experience using the front 12v vs. the rear 12v seems to indicate that, as stated on the Waeco website, the wiring to the rear 12v outlet may be insufficient to carry the necessary voltage when the engine is not running (though it seems to do fine when the engine IS running, as my experience at DE-III confirmed.)
Obviously, one solution would be to do what Waeco suggests and either replace the wire to the rear 12v aux port with heavier wire. A second solution (again recommended by Waeco) would be to run a separate, direct connection from the battery to an extra 12v outlet in the rear of the 4runner (or wherever I want it, I suppose.) The drawbacks to doing this are that it would require me to disassemble the interior of the 4runner in order to conceal the wiring, which is both difficult and time consuming, as well as being able to run wires through the firewall without it looking like crap or being a fire hazard.
But my question (and here's where I'm soliciting advice and information) is this: Could I possibly cure this issue by simply upgrading my battery? IOW, if I go with a red top battery that's rated for a lot of amps, wouldn't this "fade" more slowly, possibly putting out higher voltage for a longer period of time? Does that make sense? Because if this is something I could fix with a better battery, that's something that is pretty easy for me to do and doesn't require any modification of the wiring.
My next question concerns using an AC adapter for this same fridge. Waeco/Dometic sells a very nice AC adapter for this fridge, it's called the EPS-50. The good news is I can get this from Amazon. The bad news is that it costs nearly $100 ($77 + $12 for shipping - it comes from an outside vendor, not Amazon so it's not subject to their free shipping benefit.)
As an alternative, I could look at a less expensive one, but I'm concerned that it might not work.
I tried a non-Waeco adapter once before and it did not work at all! But I can't figure out why it didn't work. Power is power, right? As long as the adapter is putting out sufficient amps, it should work, shouldn't it?
This, again, is where I'm getting confused, especially as to the specs of the fridge.
Here are the specs on the fridge (I downloaded this from an Australian Waeco web site): Rated current at 12vDC is 3.1A. Rated current at 24vDC is 1.9A.
Now, that seems reasonable, yes? Except that the sticker on the bottom of my CF-18 reads as follows: Power consumption: 12/24v DC: “7.0A,3.0A”
Can that be right? Why would the various manuals indicate a 3.1 or 2.something amp draw when the fridge itself indicates 7? And doesn't 7 seem excessive for a small fridge like this? (NOTE: I have to look for the manual that came with the fridge, I think it's in my garage somewhere, but I'm pretty sure it also said 7A draw.)
The EPS-50 (the expensive adapter made by Waeco for this fridge) is rated as follows: Input: 110/240v AC, output is 27v DC, 150w, 6A. Even though the manufacturer specifically says this will work on my fridge, I'm reluctant to spend the $$ to order it because if its rated output is 6A, then it probably won't work (at least, I don't see how it could, if the fridge is rated to draw 7A.)
OTOH, the much less expensive Schumaker PC-16 is rated as follows: Input: 110/120v AC. Output: 12v, 6a. No wattage output is included. I could look for a 10a 110v – 12v converter, but from what I've seen these aren't easy to find with the cigarette-lighter type socket. Seems to me if the 6A Waeco adapter will work there's no reason that the 6A Schumaker adapter won't.
[EDIT: Whoops, just saw my math error there. The Waeco adapter is rated at 150W, 6a - at 27v DC!, that means that at 12v DC, it is putting out 12.5A - more than enough to run a 7A fridge! (150w / 12v DC = 12.5A)]
BTW, I just bought a digital multimeter and will be voltage testing the outlets tonight, so stay tuned!
OK, so let me start off with my issue:
Last year, following the DE-II in Moab, I decided I needed to get a fridge. I got a small one, a Dometic (Waeco) CF-18, which is a 19 liter fridge. My thought then was that the fridge would have stuff that I needed to keep cold (cheese, milk, meat) and that anything where cold was "nice but not necessary" (water, beer, soda) could go in a cooler.
That system worked out pretty well, however, I have had some "issues" with my Dometic fridge. Not that there's anything wrong with it, necessarily, just that it has some quirky features that I need to find a way to work with.
Here are the symptoms that have manifested themselves:
1. Plug the fridge into the 12v aux power socket near the tailgate of my 4runner (NOTE: Earlier this year I did the "jumper" modification to keep the 12v aux outlets powered all the time, so this gets power even when the ignition is off.) The 4runner has been parked for several days at this point (it's not my DD.) I put a bottle of warm water in the fridge to see how well it would cool overnight. Green light comes on (compressor on) but I'm also getting an intermittent red "error" light flashing (see below for description of this from the Waeco web site.)
2. Next morning, come out and check the bottle. Although the green light is on (with the intermittently flashing red "error" light), the bottle is warm.
3. Leaving everything connected, start the truck. Spend about 10 minutes with engine running hooking up the trailer. Drive trailer to trailer repair place to have some welding done. Turn off truck for about 10 minutes. After dropping off trailer, start truck up and drive to work, approximately 13 miles, maybe 25 minutes total. Turn off truck. Fridge is still plugged in to the REAR power outlet with error light intermittently flashing.
4. 11am: Come out to the truck to check the water bottle. It's nice and cold. Still having error light flashing, but it seems to be cooling OK. Incidentally, this has also been my experience on DE-III and on our recent camping trip to Canon City last weekend: Even if the error light is flashing, if the truck is running the fridge will work fine.
5. I also have a 12v plug with alligator clips that I can attach directly to the battery (bypassing the wiring.) I used this on DE-III. Usually when I had this connected to the battery, I got a solid green light with no flashing "error" light (although I did, sometimes, get the flashing error light, sometimes not. Typically if the truck is runnning or has been running for a while, the light is solid green. If the truck has been turned off for a while, the light is green with the intermittently flashing error light.)
6. Just to see if maybe the problem was the wiring to the REAR 12v outlet, last night I connected the fridge to the FRONT 12v outlet. The truck had actually been turned off for some time and yet, I got a green light with no “error” light flashing. Put the water bottle in and left it overnight. Next morning, checked it. Fridge cold, red “error” light flashing, and bottle so cold it had actually partially frozen!
Now, the above is the description of what is happening. Here's my theory on what is going on.
I don't know about the ARB, Engel, Norcold or other fridges, but one feature of the Dometic/Waeco fridges is the automatic cut off that is designed to prevent the battery from being discharged. Depending on the setting, it will cut power to the fridge when it detects a power drop, again this is to preserve the battery.
The web site for the Dometic/Waeco fridges says this:
With all DC refrigerators you must have enough voltage to run them properly, The battery in any vehicle can run your fridge just fine, even a small battery, but your must get all the voltage to the fridge not just some of it.
When running on a 12 volt car battery and with the switch on the fridge set to LOW (meaning lowest cut out battery protection voltage) the controller is very accurately set to cut off the unit to protect your battery if it sees less than 10.2 volts at the fridge. It must be understood that the voltage the fridge sees after it comes through the vehicle wiring and the cigarette socket not the voltage at the battery. You must deduct the voltages losses caused by your vehicle.
Regarding the intermittently flashing red error light, the FAQ says:
If the error light on your fridge flashes once every 5 seconds, it is definitely indicating that you have a voltage drop problem. This means that the wiring in your car may be inadequate to carry the correct amount of volts to the fridge.
The FAQ goes on to elaborate that
We have been receiving feedback from customers that the cigarette lighter in many vehicles, even some late model 4WDs is not adequate to the battery power correctly to the fridge, either the wiring is too thin or the cigarette lighter or accessory socket is dirty or has poor contacts. Both of these will create voltage drop and if it is enough, the computer in the fridge will see it as too low and turn off.
You can prove that there is absolutely no problem with any WAECO fridge by plugging it into an AC adaptor and you will see that it works perfectly, proving that it is in fact perfect. This is because the correct battery voltage is coming directly from the AC adaptor and is not loosing voltage by running through your car wiring or cigarette lighter socket. If the fridge stops after a few minutes and flashes the red low voltage warning light then your wiring is creating at least 2.5 volts loss. Battery voltage normally 12.2 with the engine stopped, less 2.5 volts loss in car wiring leaves only 9.7 at the fridge. So the fridge computer thinks your battery is flat and turns itself off to save it. It's that simple!
The solution is also simple! Replace the two wires from your battery to the cigarette light with thicker wire of at least 6 mm cross section (this does not mean 6mm thick it is just the way wiring is rated. Your auto electrician can sell you the right wire). An even better solution is to wire a special socket in the vehicle directly back to the battery in at least 6mm wire and you will never have to consider this problem again. The other advantage of a direct connection is that you do not need to have the vehicle ignition switch turned on to run the fridge. This is in fact another major cause of low voltage because when you turn the ignition to the accessories position, you can just imagine how many other things in your car are now also turned on and draining power. This also lowers the voltage available to the fridge in just the same way the lights dim in your house when something big starts up like and air conditioner.
SO, what I think is happening is this: When the engine of the truck is running[/B (and the alternator is being powered) the voltage is high enough to keep the fridge running even through the wiring that goes back to the 12v aux plug in the back of the truck. When I shut the engine off, there is still enough power to run it, but this power diminishes over time and if I leave the truck off long enough (like when I had the truck parked for 4 days without running it), it produces insufficient voltage, which the low-voltage detector in the fridge "sees" and this prevents the fridge from working.
Furthermore, my experience using the front 12v vs. the rear 12v seems to indicate that, as stated on the Waeco website, the wiring to the rear 12v outlet may be insufficient to carry the necessary voltage when the engine is not running (though it seems to do fine when the engine IS running, as my experience at DE-III confirmed.)
Obviously, one solution would be to do what Waeco suggests and either replace the wire to the rear 12v aux port with heavier wire. A second solution (again recommended by Waeco) would be to run a separate, direct connection from the battery to an extra 12v outlet in the rear of the 4runner (or wherever I want it, I suppose.) The drawbacks to doing this are that it would require me to disassemble the interior of the 4runner in order to conceal the wiring, which is both difficult and time consuming, as well as being able to run wires through the firewall without it looking like crap or being a fire hazard.
But my question (and here's where I'm soliciting advice and information) is this: Could I possibly cure this issue by simply upgrading my battery? IOW, if I go with a red top battery that's rated for a lot of amps, wouldn't this "fade" more slowly, possibly putting out higher voltage for a longer period of time? Does that make sense? Because if this is something I could fix with a better battery, that's something that is pretty easy for me to do and doesn't require any modification of the wiring.
My next question concerns using an AC adapter for this same fridge. Waeco/Dometic sells a very nice AC adapter for this fridge, it's called the EPS-50. The good news is I can get this from Amazon. The bad news is that it costs nearly $100 ($77 + $12 for shipping - it comes from an outside vendor, not Amazon so it's not subject to their free shipping benefit.)
As an alternative, I could look at a less expensive one, but I'm concerned that it might not work.
I tried a non-Waeco adapter once before and it did not work at all! But I can't figure out why it didn't work. Power is power, right? As long as the adapter is putting out sufficient amps, it should work, shouldn't it?
This, again, is where I'm getting confused, especially as to the specs of the fridge.
Here are the specs on the fridge (I downloaded this from an Australian Waeco web site): Rated current at 12vDC is 3.1A. Rated current at 24vDC is 1.9A.
Now, that seems reasonable, yes? Except that the sticker on the bottom of my CF-18 reads as follows: Power consumption: 12/24v DC: “7.0A,3.0A”
Can that be right? Why would the various manuals indicate a 3.1 or 2.something amp draw when the fridge itself indicates 7? And doesn't 7 seem excessive for a small fridge like this? (NOTE: I have to look for the manual that came with the fridge, I think it's in my garage somewhere, but I'm pretty sure it also said 7A draw.)
The EPS-50 (the expensive adapter made by Waeco for this fridge) is rated as follows: Input: 110/240v AC, output is 27v DC, 150w, 6A. Even though the manufacturer specifically says this will work on my fridge, I'm reluctant to spend the $$ to order it because if its rated output is 6A, then it probably won't work (at least, I don't see how it could, if the fridge is rated to draw 7A.)
OTOH, the much less expensive Schumaker PC-16 is rated as follows: Input: 110/120v AC. Output: 12v, 6a. No wattage output is included. I could look for a 10a 110v – 12v converter, but from what I've seen these aren't easy to find with the cigarette-lighter type socket. Seems to me if the 6A Waeco adapter will work there's no reason that the 6A Schumaker adapter won't.
[EDIT: Whoops, just saw my math error there. The Waeco adapter is rated at 150W, 6a - at 27v DC!, that means that at 12v DC, it is putting out 12.5A - more than enough to run a 7A fridge! (150w / 12v DC = 12.5A)]
BTW, I just bought a digital multimeter and will be voltage testing the outlets tonight, so stay tuned!
Last edited: