WillBeck
Adventurer
Sorry to dig up this thread, but I'm on the hunt for a pair of boots, and am planning to visit the local RedWing this week.
On a personal note, I was issued Corcoran jump boots in a very shiny black leather... Always paid to have them polished, I never was able to get that glass like coat on them. They are impossible to break in, and have absolutely no feel through the sole. Don't bother trying to drive a manual transmission in them haha. But they look ridiculously ************ when bloused in dress uniform, matched with a maroon beret...
On a personal note, I was issued Corcoran jump boots in a very shiny black leather... Always paid to have them polished, I never was able to get that glass like coat on them. They are impossible to break in, and have absolutely no feel through the sole. Don't bother trying to drive a manual transmission in them haha. But they look ridiculously ************ when bloused in dress uniform, matched with a maroon beret...
For some reason I never saw a reply notification for this. Sorry the RW try did not work out. It would have been interesting to see what the Brannock showed for your arch vs. toe length measurements. From the sounds of it you have the old "long arch short toes" foot shape. If you ever get a chance to, try on a pair of Corcoran jump boots. They use the "Munson" last, which has very firm heel fit but has good room in the toe box. It looks like RW is building a Heritage boot using that last now from what I just saw doing a quick google. The rep for that stuff is going to visit me Weds this week, and I'll ask him if they are available. I have a pair of Corcorans I had built for me in an A width many years ago in the old WW2 brown, and other than the soles being dead flat and hard as a rock I love the damn things.
Looking at the links you posted, I see the boots that work for you are very soft and relatively formless. That kind of shoe is very easy on the feet and forgiving of odd foot shapes. It'll be tough to get that sort of feel out of a more structured and harder boot. But keep trying, you'll stumble across something someday.