I am not going to argue with you but simply point out that dogs need air to cool. They pant. Your vehicle is an enclosed space. I will say it again, your vehicle is an enclosed space. The Calif. law states your window(s) must be at least 4 inches open for ventilation. This is because people have killed their dogs keeping them in crates in cars. Your crates do not provide enough air circulation. Your vehicle inside temps can become extreme in just a couple three minutes, even on a cloudy day.
personally I would fabricate a mesh door. Easy enough to do by finding an old bbq grill from say the recycling yard, cutting it to size and using some simple hinges.
THEN I would get a 12 volt fan and run it inside the car when parked.
My post to you is an attempt to educate you on these things. Not to try and make you feel bad or get defensive. My wife works at a humane society in our area and sees dogs killed by what you have built. Heat is more serious than it may appear.
Well I slept at a Holiday Inn last night. :smiley_drive: JK
To get back on topic and to clarify the use case for everyone, the dog box is for transport only. I don't think it was the intention of this thread to discuss how to leave a dog in a hot car unattended. It was simply how to best maximize storage when also transporting an animal. I travel with two big dogs, and can personally vouch for how much less storage space I have when my mutts are in the vehicle with me. It's packed tight.
My dog box is a custom size to maximize the space for storage in the back of my Land Cruiser, while also giving a protected space for my dogs. With all the gear I carry, my dogs need protection from getting banged up in the back from shifting gear, slamming against the sides of the vehicle on windy roads/rough terrain, or in the event of an accident. It also contains all the nastiness that might come out of my dogs in the event my dog gets car sick! The $15 example you recommend doesn't provide any protection. It might even increase the chance of injury. It is not a good alternative in my opinion.
When I'm driving with my dogs, the windows are open in the back and/or the air conditioning is on. It is not recommended to leave a dog in a car unattended for any length of time. Of course, there are exceptions like when the car is automatically climate controlled, but for me I don't do that. I don't take my dogs with me if I am planning to leave the vehicle and I can't tie them up outside the vehicle in a shaded/protected area.
The addition of a fan set on a thermostat is a great idea. I don't feel I need it but if you were planning to leave dogs unattended in a vehicle that would be required at a minimum I think (I still wouldn't do that even with a fan if it was hot out).
Regarding your suggestion about air flow. I do agree that more is generally better, unless it's really cold and you also need insulation. As it is, the box has 40, 2 1/4 inch holes all around. The holes are placed in the upper part of the box, which helps let heat escape. Since I don't need an insulated box, I decided to cut some more holes in the back and the front. Now there are a total of 70, 2 1/4 inch holes starting at about 12 inches up from the base. Really it is just a minor modification but as an added benefit it also lightens the box a bit. Either way the box will be at ambient temperature to the truck, and since I am not leaving dogs in the box unattended, this will be fine (IMO).
Note, I did not go further down with holes, nor did I put holes in the roof, because I also use this box in the back of my pick-up truck and on the ground as a kennel when camping. In the bed of the pick up there can be a lot of wind, I want my dogs to be able to lay down and get out of the way of the air "circulation", if they want to, and be protected from weather with a solid roof. My choices in where to put ventilation reflect my intended uses.
My intention of sharing this design is to show people an option for protecting their animals while also maximizing space in the rear of their vehicle. This dog box might not be for everyone, but it does what I want it to do. I've been using it for awhile and so far dogs are happy and healthy.
Thank you for alluding to some improvements in my design. However, calling this dog box inhumane was inappropriate. You have no basis for that accusation because you don't have enough background. Common sense dictates that having an unattended dog in a car, with or without a box, is risky without some sort of temperature monitoring and a way to keep the car cool. Some would say that even with these fail-safes, you shouldn't do it.
Enough on this! For all the other folks reading this thread, here's a few pics of the box, finished in white and with the added holes. If you like it, great. I hope it gives you some ideas. If not, no problem. There is no one-size fits all. :victory:
20140217_134931
20140217_134916
20140217_135032
20140217_135003