Ranchero
Wanderer
I was in almost the same boat. Had grown out of our 94 extended cab 4x4 (kid). Even with 33s regeared with 4.88s, it would get 20mpg under all conditions. I moved to a 96 cruiser, bumpers, rack, winch, 305s regeared with 4.56s. Super reliable, comfortable and capable. Pretty consistently get 15mpg, but I don't drive over 65. If money were no object, I would build a 2001-2005 four door Tacoma. I figure a Tacoma built like my cruiser would cost ten grand more than the$ 8-9k I have in mine. FZJs are dirt cheap.