pack size weight setup thoughts
free standing can be nice most all need staking down but the stakes are more stabilizing in mild weather than needed
where do you camp ? some parks have a tent pad and ones in the over 12x12 can not fit in a pad sometimes ? something to think about if not a issue then no worries
pack size and weight self explaining
huge pickup plenty of room not as much issue but small car etc.. that might matter
kodiak tents are awesome but heavy and non free standing but being canvas they are awesome at keeping cool in the summer and warmer in the winter and offer great family room inside have a great vestibule etc..
one of the better tents for comfort size etc.. but they weigh over 70 lbs ? lots of threads here on this tent
the big agnes flying diamond 8 is a awesome family tent and like the above 4 season which is nice even if you are not out in 4 seasons of weather
both the above are a bit more $$$ but worth it if you can swing it
next in line I would be looking at REI kingdom and then base camp when on sale often %20 off they are great tents for the price and many here use them and swear by them
when looking IMHO a covered vestibule to walk in and out of are a nice thing to have ones that doors open to the weather are not as nice once you have the vestibule