Jwestpro
Explorer
The intended purpose of the truck is to be as good as possible in snowy/icy/wintery conditions, but also have the capability to get off the pavement and do some adventuring. I am a student in Colorado, do a good deal of backcountry skiing, and this is to be my go-everywhere/handle-everything mountain truck
You stated this yet it sounds like you are jumping on the bandwagon or are going for looks more than true function.
The minute you want to be playing off road and end up putting 50% of the vehicle weight onto two tires you have pushed a non E rated tire to near or past it's intended design. Why not be safe and stick with sizes available in E load rating? Additionally, these tires should last long enough you may very well end up with more weight in the vehicle during their effective life span in a few years.
If I had to choose an SL Duratrac vs an E BFG AT KO (1), then it would be the BFG no question.
You also said "as good as possible in winter". That is not the Duratrac. It should be "fine" but definitely not "as good as possible". So either what you said is irrelevant and you have changed your mind or you are caving in to the popularity of the Goodyear. The large blocks on the Duratrac are not going to be the "best" in winter. The compound itself is definitely not either. People in Canada run the Rotiva and love it. Like the Nokian WRG2 and similar, they will also wear well in the summer.
However, if you can manage it, you sound like a perfect candidate for 2 sets of wheels. Many people with these rarely get much winter travel so an AT will be fine with the rare trip into snow. You, however, plan to be in it for large durations of the season. Get snows for winter or at least something like the Rotiva.