I'm not the most experienced, but I'd agree. A superwinch with 9600 lb rating can be had off amazon for ~$600 with synthetic line. It's not the best in the business, but it's a decent winch.
Also... having your brakes go out isn't exactly "reliably and safely". That should've been #1 on the list, before even working on the engine.
I feel like I need bumpers on my current build (I back in to trees, and I want a winch), but I'm going tube 'cause it saves a bundle. I also don't want the rear-access blocked, so no swingout. This means my total for bumpers is under a thousand. They needed a place for the spare I suppose, so a swingout was something of a necessity for that particular rig? *shrug*.