Normally I would agree, but not in the case of an EGR.
As much as it may reduce the NOX levels, an EGR can totally clog up your intake manifold, make you use more fuel and reduce it's lifespan, as well as other things. In my opinion, an EGR has far more negatives than it has positives.
I have said it before and I will say it again... the engineer/s who designed the EGR system should have been slapped by the side of the head!
You weren't trying hard enough.
My plate is 3mm thick and is fitted between the manifold and the cross-over pipe. That is the only place I have blocked the EGR system.
From memory, I did not use the OEM gasket; just some hi temp RTV sealant. Been that way for over 5 years now and I don't have any leaks, nor have I had any engine codes.
Removing the whole ERG system was not really an option for me, as it would have drawn too much attention at registration time.