MTCK
Observer
Good debate. From my own experience I've run an overloaded 1/2 ton domestic truck, overloaded first gen Tacoma with airbags, and a one ton under gvw. For me it all comes down to comfort and piece of mind. I did not enjoy driving the overloaded rigs extended distances over poor roads and in bad weather. I would have to slow down, the trucks would sway in the wind and bounce and bottom out on large potholes and frost heaves. I also hate being underpowered and having to crawl up passes loaded so that was a consideration with my current truck.
I think you are spot on with your cab and a half full size with a six foot bed. Check out a FWC Hawk, Hallmark Milner (sp?), ATC, Phoenix etc and see how much insulation and storage you think you need. For trucks you should be able to get that cab/bed configuration in all of the following and I would go test drive some:
GM 2500hd, gas or diesel will have 10.5 or 11.5 full floating rear. 6.0 gas is totally adequate for most missions.
Ford F-250 super duty and Ram 2500 I would consider too as you can get gas or diesel and a solid front axle and full floating rear.
Ford, GM or Ram 1/2 tons with the 3.5 ecoboost, 6.2 LS V8, 5.7 hemi or little ram diesel that I know nothing about. All semifloating rear ends and smaller drive trains / lighter suspensions but worth test driving.
Last but certainly not least, Toyota Tundra with a 5.7 or Nissan Titan with a 5.6. Semi floating rears again, but the tundra has a pretty beefy 10.5" ring gear in it.
If it was me I would probably pick up the GM 2500hd gasser if I liked having more truck than load or the tundra if I thought I could live with the 1/2 ton. Good luck.
I think you are spot on with your cab and a half full size with a six foot bed. Check out a FWC Hawk, Hallmark Milner (sp?), ATC, Phoenix etc and see how much insulation and storage you think you need. For trucks you should be able to get that cab/bed configuration in all of the following and I would go test drive some:
GM 2500hd, gas or diesel will have 10.5 or 11.5 full floating rear. 6.0 gas is totally adequate for most missions.
Ford F-250 super duty and Ram 2500 I would consider too as you can get gas or diesel and a solid front axle and full floating rear.
Ford, GM or Ram 1/2 tons with the 3.5 ecoboost, 6.2 LS V8, 5.7 hemi or little ram diesel that I know nothing about. All semifloating rear ends and smaller drive trains / lighter suspensions but worth test driving.
Last but certainly not least, Toyota Tundra with a 5.7 or Nissan Titan with a 5.6. Semi floating rears again, but the tundra has a pretty beefy 10.5" ring gear in it.
If it was me I would probably pick up the GM 2500hd gasser if I liked having more truck than load or the tundra if I thought I could live with the 1/2 ton. Good luck.