My top is off for as long as I can on my YJ wrangler. Even my soft top has a tendancy to be down more than up. I have a rack for it to. It is an Olympic. Yes I can not take the windsheild down anymore, but since the Snorkle make it impossible anyway, this is not realy major.
The problem with any safari style rack for soft top jeep is that non is perfect. I had to modifiy and reinforce my olympic. It also have to be high so I can take my soft top down without having to lift the rack up.
Like I say, a top rack on a wrangler type jeep will always be a compromise.
But we do this for the overland, nut for the pure look of it!
Happy trails and happy holidays!