Interesting thread for sure. I have not been Defenderless since '93. They are great trucks, extremely capable, easily modified and obviously hold their value well. One point to remember is they began production in late '82 as an '83 model and have been slowly refined to current standards. Those current standards are worlds apart from the NAS models of '94, '95, and '97. During that same time frame, Jeep has gone from CJ to YJ to TJ and finally JK- also worlds apart from the early 80's. Point being the Defender has been tweaked and tweaked while the JK has evolved from 4 distinct generational/model changes. Jeep has kept it's focus while improving each model to the point of having a very comfortable AND capable rig- whether DD or Expedition duties. Spending a day -much less several days exploring or traveling, will definitely show the vehicle's differences in ergonomics as well as NVH, etc. The Defender didn't even have a/c incorporated into the HVAC system until '07!! The two are in fact two different trucks, but aim at basically the same target: Jeep is shooting with modern weaponry while LR is still using spears.
It is also a good example to look at a Defender chassis/suspension and realize it has not changed since '83- fully boxed, coils, etc. -quite ahead of it's time then. While it took Jeep a while to catch up, they have subsequently passed the prior benchmark, while adding modern amenities. The irony is we as enthusiast want all the modern amenities and comforts and even the smoothness and performance and power of things like direct fuel injection, etc. but don't want the needed electronics to manage same.
It is true of other vehicles as well. I have an '11 F250 diesel with 400hp and 800 ft lb of torque as well heated and cooled seats, rear camera, etc. I also have an '84 Chevy diesel M1028 sans a/c w/ crank windows. Both have their value.
In summary, it is impressive to me LR can still compete using 30 year old design and basically an unchanged suspension system compared to all the computer derived vehicles of modern day.
I love my Rovers, but push come to shove- my JKU would be the last vehicle for me to sell. In fact the JKU is the best 'jack of all trades' in my book.
Just my 2c...