For what it's worth...
1999 Mitsubishi Montero SR [U.S. Version] 3.5L / Automatic
Completely stock.
Currently installed with [as purchased] - pathetic - Futura "street tread" tires [P265/70R15]... which are not long for this world.
Tires are inflated @ 31psi [using nitrogen].
Mostly driven on city streets, with occasional highway miles.
Consistently returns 20mpg, using 89 octane [Costco fuel stations].
It is driven [90% of the time] like an elderly woman would drive it, in the Los Angeles area... in other words, no quick getaways from traffic lights, anticipating stops.
Most of the driving is on level streets, lots of stop & go traffic, with minimal hills/ mountains encountered.
If I drove it like a scalded cat I would never see 20mpg... driving up and down mountains, ditto.
Would I ever trade it for something else? Hell no.
Honestly, I do not miss my Landcruiser FJ60 one bit [okay, a smidgeon]... especially with its - perfect operating condition - 12mpg, having a wind at its back, and falling off a cliff.
Bigger [fatter] tires / Lower inflated tires / Agressive tread pattern designs / Taller vehicle profile = demonstrable drop in fuel mileage returns... but you have to admit, they do look more **************'.