You are absolutely right!
Have they changed the top design? Our black top was white on the inside and throughout. When it got scratched, white shown through. This was part of our decision for choosing white. Teach me Obi Wan.
I'm not Obi, but if I may cut in.....the top has not been changed one bit except the sharper, squarer (is that a word?), top corners of the 2011's and up. It definately scratches, I think he was referring more to the scratching of the paint if he were to paint the green Jeep's hard top a matching green.
I just drug (literally) my 2011 Jeep's hard top through 800 miles of Oregon's 6 ft. tall, Madrona bush choked backroads doing Route 3 of the OBDR a couple of months ago and still have the pinstripes to show for it. My JK was 3 weeks old when I started the trip so to say I had a quick break in time was an understatement, but I bought it to use it, not abuse it.