Hey man, I know exactly where you are coming from. I did precisely the same thing, going from 2002 SC SE Xterra to a 2005 X. The newer Gen has a much, much better engine that is a lot more fuel efficient. I think you would love the next gen Frontier. Cheers and good luck
That's sad to hear. My wife's first gen is a bit of a gas hog too but she loves it and its not nearly as bad as what you're getting. If hers dropped that low I'd start looking for issues. I don't always keep track but with steel wheels and really heavy Goodyear MTRs I think the lowest ive seen is 11 or 12.
16.4 gallons...145 miles...that's closer to 8.8 mpg. Is that really where your truck is sitting mpg-wise? I hate to see such a dedicated owner/build thread throw in the towel (I just started following your thread, great pics/commentary) because of poor mileage.
I noticed a few pages back you were speaking with Steven Lutz...have you picked his brain on your mileage issues? I can relate to the weight issue myself, but even on my worst days with my mod-set up I'm grabbing 10-12 mpg...15-16 highway loaded for Moab.
Respect your Gen II Fronty wishes...just dig your truck and hate to see it go. Best of luck with the new direction.
I can relate to these numbers, I was regularly in the 11s on highway and sub 10s in the city. It continued until i did 2 things, relocate the knock sensor and actually pay attention to the cfms that the SC demands. After I resolved those two issues, getting 14-15 highway and 13 city. Averaging 200-220 miles per tank. Its been a long road, Check out my fuelly chart (log book, show last 100)
http://www.fuelly.com/driver/stiflersmom/xterra
Showing the last 100 fuelups, you can see 10/18/11 when I did the knock sensor relocate, and mpgs dipped again 7/11/13 when i tried to figure out the sealed snork, 8/18/12 through 6/7/13 was running stock airbox, no snork connected.
Still a far cry from the newer model X and fronties, but much more manageable. I dont want to sway you, but love the truck and its build.
That being said, i would wait a year or so to see if they really do end up with a diesel fronty.
It's understandable, but I feel like the newer Frontier will be a far better platform to do what I'm looking to do. I know what I have now is a nicely outfitted truck and all that, but I've always had my eye on a second gen. It's the truck I've been wanting since I got rid of my Land Rover. The greatly increased range would be enough to sway me, but the nicer interior, ride comfort, and exterior looks all help. Couple all this with something else I've been thinking about...
I'm engaged, planning to start a family within the next five or so years. Having more interior space is important. I'm thinking long term, and the extra space for a family is something important.
I know a lot of people are bummed out that this build is ending, and I'm bummed too. But I don't feel like it's a good idea to continue putting money into a truck I'm unhappy with.
I would love to have a diesel Frontier. I think it's going to happen, but not until the next generation/body style. And I don't have the money for a brand new truck. I'll probably be able to afford a sub 100k 2005-2008, hopefully a Nismo.
Good luck sir, looking forward to the new hawtness!
Good luck sir, looking forward to the new hawtness!
Agreed, and I would wait for one with the locker, even if it takes a little longer, I think it will pay off in the end
The early second gens had a weaker locker. If you want a 6speed you'll have a hard enough time finding one without a locker. 6speeds with a locker are a unicorn of sorts.
So sad to see Nancy go. But I'm in the same boat; I understand your pain!
Hell, I've been looking at Gen 2 Frontiers myself...
Good luck in your quest to get a gen 2. Looks like your truck was built up well, looking forward to seeing what you do with one of these.
Which parts are you planning on carrying over to the new fronty, if any?
Aside from custom stuff there is no carryover between gen 1 and 2.