Andy, if you were to choose between M8274-50 and 9500XP, for your personal truck. Assuming they both fit the bumper. Which would you choose? No need to give reasons.
The fit problem will be a big determining factor. I drug a Bronco though all sorts of stupid mud with an XD9000. it was plenty. The high free-spool speed is important to get the wich cought up once you start to un-stick. For mymoney, I'd go with the smaller winch- bigger is NOT always better.