The 10 Year Commitment

Saguache

Adventurer
We've met before, but it might be good if I re-introduced myself. My name is Matt and I have a vehicle modification habit. My friends and family have all tried to help me with this problem, but as hard as they try I pick up one car or bike or what ever after another and then begin to tinker with the damn thing until I get tired of it and move on to the next thing. The good news is that I usually learn a lot from each of these little experiments. The bad news is that each and every one of them turn into a whole in the ground where I toss money.

I didn't grow up that way. My Dad who is now 65 still owns the jeep he bought in 1984. You can see it in the image below (that's me in the foreground) on a trip around the Alpine Loop here in Colorado.

2811709378_088b6a80bc.jpg

Sure its seen better days, but that rust bucket of a crap heap is still driving over and around and through as well as it did (with perhaps a little less style) back when it was fresh minted off the AMC factory floor.

I've built new, I've built old and the same thing pretty much happens every time. I build for a while and then get bored and sell it.

So, fair friends, I need help. My wife and much better half has given me an ultimatum. Find a vehicle I can be happy with for the next 10 years. So the search begins and inevitably my browser wonders in this direction and I see all the cool things you guys are doing to a variety of vehicle platforms that makes me drool with envy. Pick one, yea right. Ok how in the world am I going to pick one?

I've got a short list of requirements which I've hacked out below. In addition to this its important to note that I have a family. Usually there are three of us -- myself, my wife and our two year old. I have a 15 year old too who comes along when I can get the time from his mother (my ex). And finally, we like to take our dogs with as well (two, medium sized), but one of them is getting older and won't be with us too much longer. Come to think of it, the second won't make it to the end of the 10 year commitment unless she's very lucky, so the dogs coming is sort of temporary. Most of the trips I do in most of the vehicles I've worked on I've been the only occupant (with dogs).

Requirements:
  • Vehicle should be pretty efficient: One of the more recent projects I've worked on was a 1983 VW Diesel L converted to a high top. It got on average about 32 miles per gallon. I know hard to achieve with a gasser, but I'm also not interested in paying for the amount of fuel a full sized, American truck is going to suck down. I will use this vehicle as a daily driver a lot of the time too, so its TCO has got to fall in my family's budget.
    6763454413_3db983a82f.jpg
  • Vehicle should be able to seat four comfortably: We can put the dogs in the back. The vehicle is for going from place to place. Its a utility although I don't mind if you like the way it looks. Comfort is important to us, especially me at this point. Right now we share a 2006 Subaru forester which, to me, is a lot like driving a box a magician is supposed to escape. I'm not super tall, but I'm also not super human. Three hours in that vehicle and my legs ache, five and they're numb from the knee down.
    6274178953_c19e2cf562.jpg
  • Vehicle should be agile for tougher roads (say most Jeep roads) but not a rock crawler: So I've driven a 1969 VW beetle over Engineer Pass. Not easy, but possible. Frankly I don't want to do that again. What I'd prefer to drive over Engineer is something with a little more clearance, potentially a 4x4. It doesn't have to have 33"s, but it would be nice if someday it could take them for instance. I'd actually rather some narrower BFGs with durable rubber. I don't need a super crawler, I'd much rather park it at the trail head and run for a while.
  • Should be able to sleep in vehicle easily in rain, snow, and crappy weather: Here's where I think it starts to get tricky. In the world I'd like to imagine I have an anonymous benefactor who sees what I'm trying to do and supplies me with an ever filling Swiss bank account, a large heated workspace, and more tools than I know what to do with. In this world I can make an RV that makes that six wheeled thing they had on the old Battle Star look silly. In this world, one of the things my wife has said is that it would be super cool if, when the weather ********************** outside, all I had to do to go to bed was slide back between the front seats. Add to this the fact that I have no anonymous benefactor and you see my challenge.
  • It would be cool if parts aren't a nightmare: As cool as the VW was, parts were a freakin nightmare. I mean, have you ever tried to source the little bits of plastic that raise the winder sliders 2 mm so that they click shut? For this reason, I'm apt to chose newer over older. I've missed too many trail races and fun events because I was MacGyver-ing the hell out of something for which I needed a part. No more machine shop specials, no more out of production machines.
  • There should be at least a little aftermarket (here in the US): For somethings I've learned its nice to be able to go to the catalog and just pick out the modification you're looking for. Sure, once it arrives in its brown box you might loose a little knuckle skin getting it in, but you can smile too because you know you're not going to have to weld anything. You don't need an electrical engineering degree to make it work (the diagrams right there with pictures and everything). And there's probably someone on the other end of the phone line who can walk you through installation or whatever because you're too dense to orient the instructions the right way.
  • I should be at least a little familiar with the damn thing: In other words, lower the learning curve. I've messed around with a lot of VWs, Subarus, and Toyotas. Plus I have lots of military vehicle experience from the 90's. I want to be able to look under the hood and know where the water pump is, and potentially why its making that sound when I turn left. I realize that there are some similarities, but then there are some differences between makes and models and even vintages of cars.

My short list of potential vehicles includes these listed below. I keep thinking about candidates, but these are the ones I'm sure can go on the list for research at least.

  • Toyota Tacoma Crew Cab 4x4 G2: I've owned this truck for a little while (then the ex got it and totaled it ... ouch!). It was awesome, not to big, not to gas hungry. Comfortable for me and three other people. Mostly easy to work on, with a fair aftermarket. And I could either build or buy what I need to make it overland worthy. I'm not partial to the G3s although I also haven't driven one, but it appears to me that Toyota decided that what they had wasn't *big* enough and so they changed one of the best things about their older models. The G1s on the other hand quickly run into the parts availability/reliability problem because they're just so old.
  • Toyota 4Runner G2: I've stuck with a 1995 4Runner the longest I've ever owned a vehicle. Had fun with the one I had too. Very similar to the above in the way they work out, although in either case I'd probably take it to a master mechanic and let them give me the grand list of what needed fixing before I really started working on it.
    2213224140_32f4351056.jpg
  • Jeep Wranger Unlimited: Newer and much more expensive, but these are sexy. With an awesome aftermarket who wouldn't want one. But they're also not nearly as efficient as any of the above.
  • Toyota FJ Cruiser: Sexy and new-ish, and after Toyota decided not to make them for the US anymore freakishly expensive. I've always liked these, but I also worry about parts and potential breakdowns in Guatemala. Plus they have the shortest wheelbase of anything on the list. Occasionally I see on that truly looks like its ready to serve, but then I've also seen a lot of them that look like plastic "wilderness man" toys that never make it off pavement.

Your opinions and comments are welcome. Remember I've got to like this car for the next 10 years.
 

hornytoad

Desert Geologist
I did the wrangler/Tacoma/4runner toss up last year. I chose the Tacoma double cab short bed to keep the truck nimble and the cost down. For family hauling and camping I would recommend the double cab long bed with a topper and an aftermarket suspension. the 5foot bed is too small for camping and the extra length is ok if your not wanting a rock crawler.
 

STREGA

Explorer
I'am starting my 6th year of a 10 year plan with a FJ Cruiser, thinking of pushing it out to a 15 year plan.

With your situation I would go with the crew cab Tacoma, the FJ has been a awesome rig for my wife and me but we also don't have children or large dogs. Both the Taco and FJ are holding their value, it may make more sense to purchase a new truck over a used one. Also the FJ is still being sold in the USA.
 

Flagster

Expedition Leader
My 2005 Tacoma is pushing 8 years this July...Nothing but scheduled maint and some new leaf springs...
I am expecting 10 years easy...the hard part will be trying to figure out what to replace it with...it just works so well at everything
 

Saguache

Adventurer
I did the wrangler/Tacoma/4runner toss up last year. I chose the Tacoma double cab short bed to keep the truck nimble and the cost down. For family hauling and camping I would recommend the double cab long bed with a topper and an aftermarket suspension. the 5foot bed is too small for camping and the extra length is ok if your not wanting a rock crawler.

Thanks HornyToad,

I've been thinking along those lines too, although I current already own a AutoHome Maggiolina GT (med) which I've thought about mounting above the topper. That would solve the super easy sleep problem, however, there's no pass through for my wife. That may be something she has to learn to live with. Compromises, compromises.

Another car, and it is a car, that I've been looking at is the Honda Element with an Ursa Minor ECAMPER. But man I can see problems with this. Namely, I'd be committed to driving something with x-mass tree LEDs all over the inside of it. Yuck! Plus bed/storage space is somewhat limited. Honda stopped making them in 2011. And finally because I'd have to stack up to expand my ability to bring stuff, thereby killing my formerly awesome milage.

Thanks for sharing your experience.
 

Saguache

Adventurer
I'am starting my 6th year of a 10 year plan with a FJ Cruiser, thinking of pushing it out to a 15 year plan.

With your situation I would go with the crew cab Tacoma, the FJ has been a awesome rig for my wife and me but we also don't have children or large dogs. Both the Taco and FJ are holding their value, it may make more sense to purchase a new truck over a used one. Also the FJ is still being sold in the USA.

Thanks Strega,

The more time I spend looking for FJs the more I'm realizing that I'll spend my entire wad just getting the stock vehicle. And much like the ECAMPER I'd have to go up to store everything. Thanks!
 

Saguache

Adventurer
My 2005 Tacoma is pushing 8 years this July...Nothing but scheduled maint and some new leaf springs...
I am expecting 10 years easy...the hard part will be trying to figure out what to replace it with...it just works so well at everything

See that's the sort of news I like to hear. Its working and you're happy with it.
 

Martinjmpr

Wiffleball Batter
I think you need to refine your "requirements" a little. Break them down into "must have" and "nice to have but not neccessary."

The ability to sleep 4 - sorry, that's not realistic for anything other than an RV so you might as well cross that one out right now.

Honestly, my wife found the Tacoma to be too small to sleep two comfortably, though it was perfectly fine as a solo sleeping vehicle.

Now, a double-cab Tacoma could probably sleep two people if you can sleep in a reclined seat. I've done it, but it wasn't comfortable and I didn't sleep well. But an access-cab (extra-cab) cannot be considered a realistic option if there is a need to seat 4 people. Toyota classes the Extra-cab as a 5 person vehicle (three in the front seat and two in the back) but that's a joke and not a particularly funny one.

I think an FJ Cruiser or access-cab truck would be fine for a single person, marginal for a couple and inadequate for anybody with a family to transport.

For most of your requirements I think any decent mid-sized SUV should be adequate. I've been pretty impressed with the MPG on my 4th gen 4runner (can get 18 in city driving or over 20 on the highway, which is pretty remarkable for a vehicle this size.) Another contender might be the Nissan Xterra or Pathfinder (the R51 Pathfinder, 2005 - 2012.) MPG is not great (I think they are rated at 14/20) but size is pretty good, 3 full rows of seating and enough space in the back to construct a pretty decent sleeping platform for 2 people. The 4.0 engine on the Nissan's is pretty powerful and although I can't speak to the reliability of any Nissan product, my wife just got a 2011 Altima and we're very impressed with fit, finish, overall build quality and performance. If it wasn't for a few niggling details, I might have ended up with either a Pathy or an Xterra for my off-road vehicle this past year. The X also has the advantage of being available with a manual tranny, if that's what you want (of course the FJC and Taco are also available with a manual.)

You didn't say what your budget was so it's hard to judge. The 3rd gen 4runner is a favorite here but from my experience, MPG is marginal and combined with an (IMO) inadequate gas tank size, that makes for an unacceptably short range. I'd say if you can swing it a 4th gen 4runner or 2nd gen Taco would be better.

Speaking of Tacos, you mentioned a 3rd generation? I was under the impression that we were still on the 2nd gen of Tacos. 1st gen was 1995-2004, 2nd gen is 2005 - present, with some minor cosmetic changes along the way. Is that not correct?
 

Saguache

Adventurer
Speaking of Tacos, you mentioned a 3rd generation? I was under the impression that we were still on the 2nd gen of Tacos. 1st gen was 1995-2004, 2nd gen is 2005 - present, with some minor cosmetic changes along the way. Is that not correct?

Guess I got that mixed up. I was thinking that the trucks Toyota made prior to 1995 were G1 Tacomas. So what generation would you call this?

$T2eC16VHJF8E9nnC7NzMBQ64DMeK!!~~60_3.JPG

Its labeled as a 1981 Toyota Tacoma Trekker (truck predecessor to the 4Runner).
 

tanglefoot

ExPoseur
Contrary to popular belief, the truck you posted is not a Tacoma. The model name on that is "Truck" in the US or "Hilux" overseas, or in that particular example, "Trekker". That body style is the 2nd generation of the "Truck", or the 1st gen of the 4wd Truck. The Tacoma didn't debut until the end of 1994. The first gen of the Tacoma includes model years 1995 through 2004. There were 4 generations of Trucks (3 of 4wd) before the Tacoma: 73-78 (2wd only), 79-83, 84-88 and 89-early 95.

The first Tacomas looked like this:

1995 Tacoma.jpg

Good luck with your decision. I think it'd be hard to go wrong with a Taco or 4Runner. The FJ's are nice but they're more of a niche vehicle and I think factors like the poor outward visibility and fuel economy would steer me elsewhere. I do like seeing them out there though. It really comes down to your exact needs and desires. For some, an FJ is a perfect match. I personally love 4-cylinder engines so I'd be looking for a Tacoma or 4runner with the 2.7, myself. I love the styling of the 2nd gen 4runner like your '95 but admit that the 3rd gen brought along some nice improvements such as the roomier rear seat and larger rear doors, reliable and convenient rear lift gate and more powerful engines.

I'm always hesitant to drop by the "master mechanic." The only time I took a car to one was when a buyer requested an inspection. They wanted to replace things the car didn't even have.

Good luck,

Eric
 
Last edited:

p nut

butter
In my opinion, the double cab Tacoma is the most versatile of the bunch and would fit your needs the best. Except for the sleeping in the vehicle part. The 5 ft bed is small, but the utility factor is still 10X higher than a hatchback. Aftermarket is plentiful and it is very capable stock, as you already know. Only negative is how great they hold their value, so initial cost will be higher.
 

GHR

Observer
10 years, then Toyota probably best choice though I have owned a Nissan Xterra for 10 years and a Pathfinder ahead of that with virtually no issues. if you look at a 4x4 truck or SUV in North America likely none too efficient. Sad, but we don't have models with small efficient engines like Europe and elsewhere.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
190,426
Messages
2,927,464
Members
233,917
Latest member
gp01
Top