SONICMASD
Adventurer
How to begin? Everyone knows I love my 98 Montero, AKA Black Betty. I never even dreamed about another Montero because I love how capable the Gen 2.5 is but over our 16,000 adventure miles together I've been wanting a more comfortable vehicle in terms of on and off road ride quality and steering response, interior environment, and horsepower.
I'd been intrigued by the Gen 3 since I first got into Monteros and tried to jump on a great deal that I found on Craigslist about 10 months ago but it sold within hours of posting and I missed out. My plan with that one was to just keep it stock and daily drive it even though I don't really have an interest in daily driving a car that gets sub 20 mpgs and isn't very sporty but that's how good of a deal it was and it definitely peaked my Gen3 curiosity.
So fast forward a few months and AZ Crew Mechanic In Chief, Ernest, tells me he is driving out to California with a Montero Sport Limited to flat tow back a Gen3 with a dead transmission. But not just any Gen3, the famous 2003 Limited from Imnosaint and then Marutuk's build threads. I was really excited about this because it meant that if Ernest ever decided to part with the rig, I'd hear about it and have a shot at it.
Over the next couple of months Ernest did the following maintenance:
At this point, this is how the rigged looked:
IMG_0439
IMG_0440
5/10/18:
I went wheeling with Ernest and was impressed by the Gen3. He drove it past where I felt comfortable taking Betty for fear of body damage and indeed he did get a small dent in the passenger rear rocker/door area right because the Rocky Road Sliders don't have any sort of kick out, but still - I was impressed.
I hit this steep hill with Betty with the rear locker on and a heavy dose of throttle, and so did another Gen 2.5 that we were with and we didn't have any issues. Ernest wasn't planning on doing that optional obstacle but then he was like "well, I can't be the only one who doesn't do it." So he hit it with the Gen3 and it did it almost as smoothly as our 2.5s with lockers on and we're talking about a very steep and high hill with mixed rock and loose sand.
He also managed to navigate very tight trails with low hanging branches despite the height and added width of the Gen3. And I was really blown away by how stable the rig was. On off camber situations that felt dicy on the Gen 2.5, the Gen 3 was firmly planted.
IMG_0539
IMG_0536
Shortly before this wheeling trip, Ernest had decided to sell the Gen3 because he got a JK and knowing that the vehicle was about to be posted publicly for sale I decided to go take a deeper, more in-depth look at it. I asked hundred questions, drove all around town running errands with Ernest and his kids, and he even left me take it offroad on my test drive. Sadly, the Gen3 wheel spin presented itself on this test. It's amazing how little of an obstacle will cause the Gen3 to lose traction from its lack of articulation, requiring you to give it gas and cause the traction control to kick in, and then stare at the sky as it 3 (or 2) wheels over the obstacle. It was a very strange, foreign, and unsettling feeling. For my entire 4x4 life, I've been trained not to spin my wheels and Betty very rarely does. If it happens, I immediately get off the throttle, back up and pick a better line, or throw on the rear locker - but this test confirmed that I would need to learn to drive this vehicle differently and either:
A. rely on the traction control and get really good at 3 wheelin
B. invest in a rear locker and use it a lot more than in the Gen 2.5 because of the more limited articulation
I had several reservations:
1. Betty is an amazing vehicle that I've built for my needs and she's religiously maintained
2. I know everything about Betty and am more experienced working on Gen 2s.
3. Worried about the Gen3 style of wheeling
4. Gen3s are generally known as the least reliable Montero generation (more technology / more complicated systems)
5. Gen3 needs work - lots of little miscellaneous things to fix plus the expensive locker installation
6. Exterior of the Gen3 is kinda beat up - from the sun faded bedliner rockers, hood paint, busted up rear bumper, and rolled fenders.
BUT in the end, I decided that I would give the Gen3 a shot. I mean, when else would I have an opportunity to so easily own a vehicle with all of these mods? Ernest and I made a deal and I decided to put the 2 Monteros head to head in a comprehensive test to see which one I would keep. I can't justify having 2 dedicated weekend vehicles and I just bought a new daily driver a month ago (2013 Sonata). And plus, I mostly do the same kind of wheeling all the time so even if I had both, I'd probably always drive the better vehicle (for my needs) and would probably find that the other one was just being forgotten so even though a lot of you will probably instinctively say "just keep both", it's not possible - there can be only one built Montero for me.
Because of Imnosaint's Dakar theme with rally stickers on the sides and the big Bedouin on the hood, I decided to name the new-to-me Montero: Lawrence of Arizona.
Let's get ready to rumble!
montero-battle
I'd been intrigued by the Gen 3 since I first got into Monteros and tried to jump on a great deal that I found on Craigslist about 10 months ago but it sold within hours of posting and I missed out. My plan with that one was to just keep it stock and daily drive it even though I don't really have an interest in daily driving a car that gets sub 20 mpgs and isn't very sporty but that's how good of a deal it was and it definitely peaked my Gen3 curiosity.
So fast forward a few months and AZ Crew Mechanic In Chief, Ernest, tells me he is driving out to California with a Montero Sport Limited to flat tow back a Gen3 with a dead transmission. But not just any Gen3, the famous 2003 Limited from Imnosaint and then Marutuk's build threads. I was really excited about this because it meant that if Ernest ever decided to part with the rig, I'd hear about it and have a shot at it.
Over the next couple of months Ernest did the following maintenance:
- Transmission replaced with a used one but low mileage - around 117k.
- New crankshaft bearings (main, rod, and thrust)
- New Oil Pump
- New Motor Mounts
- New o-ring in the back of passenger cyl head
- Valve cover gasket on passenger cyl head
- New inner tie rod ends
- New steering rack boots
- 4.90 gear swap
- The almost new 285/75R16 BFG KO2 tires that Marutuk bought about a year ago and the wheels they were on were switched out for 15" steelies with 35x12.50R15 BFG KO2s.
- Front brake calipers were sanded a bit to clear the 15" steel wheels.
- 1/4" wheel spacers in the front
- Front fenders rolled up about 1/2"
At this point, this is how the rigged looked:


5/10/18:
I went wheeling with Ernest and was impressed by the Gen3. He drove it past where I felt comfortable taking Betty for fear of body damage and indeed he did get a small dent in the passenger rear rocker/door area right because the Rocky Road Sliders don't have any sort of kick out, but still - I was impressed.
I hit this steep hill with Betty with the rear locker on and a heavy dose of throttle, and so did another Gen 2.5 that we were with and we didn't have any issues. Ernest wasn't planning on doing that optional obstacle but then he was like "well, I can't be the only one who doesn't do it." So he hit it with the Gen3 and it did it almost as smoothly as our 2.5s with lockers on and we're talking about a very steep and high hill with mixed rock and loose sand.
He also managed to navigate very tight trails with low hanging branches despite the height and added width of the Gen3. And I was really blown away by how stable the rig was. On off camber situations that felt dicy on the Gen 2.5, the Gen 3 was firmly planted.


Shortly before this wheeling trip, Ernest had decided to sell the Gen3 because he got a JK and knowing that the vehicle was about to be posted publicly for sale I decided to go take a deeper, more in-depth look at it. I asked hundred questions, drove all around town running errands with Ernest and his kids, and he even left me take it offroad on my test drive. Sadly, the Gen3 wheel spin presented itself on this test. It's amazing how little of an obstacle will cause the Gen3 to lose traction from its lack of articulation, requiring you to give it gas and cause the traction control to kick in, and then stare at the sky as it 3 (or 2) wheels over the obstacle. It was a very strange, foreign, and unsettling feeling. For my entire 4x4 life, I've been trained not to spin my wheels and Betty very rarely does. If it happens, I immediately get off the throttle, back up and pick a better line, or throw on the rear locker - but this test confirmed that I would need to learn to drive this vehicle differently and either:
A. rely on the traction control and get really good at 3 wheelin
B. invest in a rear locker and use it a lot more than in the Gen 2.5 because of the more limited articulation
I had several reservations:
1. Betty is an amazing vehicle that I've built for my needs and she's religiously maintained
2. I know everything about Betty and am more experienced working on Gen 2s.
3. Worried about the Gen3 style of wheeling
4. Gen3s are generally known as the least reliable Montero generation (more technology / more complicated systems)
5. Gen3 needs work - lots of little miscellaneous things to fix plus the expensive locker installation
6. Exterior of the Gen3 is kinda beat up - from the sun faded bedliner rockers, hood paint, busted up rear bumper, and rolled fenders.
BUT in the end, I decided that I would give the Gen3 a shot. I mean, when else would I have an opportunity to so easily own a vehicle with all of these mods? Ernest and I made a deal and I decided to put the 2 Monteros head to head in a comprehensive test to see which one I would keep. I can't justify having 2 dedicated weekend vehicles and I just bought a new daily driver a month ago (2013 Sonata). And plus, I mostly do the same kind of wheeling all the time so even if I had both, I'd probably always drive the better vehicle (for my needs) and would probably find that the other one was just being forgotten so even though a lot of you will probably instinctively say "just keep both", it's not possible - there can be only one built Montero for me.
Because of Imnosaint's Dakar theme with rally stickers on the sides and the big Bedouin on the hood, I decided to name the new-to-me Montero: Lawrence of Arizona.
Let's get ready to rumble!
