So I have a 2000x2000 knockoff ebay awning and the ARB deluxe that I've slept in probably a dozen times or so. I'm torn on it.
I already had the awning and kinda wanted my camping setup attached to my vehicle for some reason. In hindsight I don't know why. Once we set up camp we don't really move much at all, but for some reason I still find the awning room to be a bit more trouble than it's worth. Since I already had the awning, the awning room was only another $170~, so not a huge investment, and if you already have the awning it's really not a bad purchase to use as a foul weather changing room or something. But if I could do it again I'd either go with an oztent or a camping swag.
My issue with the awning room is why even have it attached to the vehicle? It takes longer to set up than a regular tent, and you lose the ability to use the awning during the day. Also it doesn't pack up small. So usually in my trunk I have the awning room, a sleeping bag, a foam sleeping pad, and a self inflating pad. That's a lot of trunk space dedicated to one person's sleeping set up. This is why I'm planning on switching to a swag. Even though swags definitely don't pack up small, it'd probably be on my roof. Also it's nice to just open up the swag and throw a sleeping back in it, not have to have 2 different sleeping pads, plus a bag and the tent. Sure I could streamline this down and get a better sleeping pad but I think I'm just moving away from the awning room, and swags seem to cost about the same as expeds.
I'll still keep the awning room for when the ladyfriend comes camping, plus it's nice to be able to stand up in it to change and whatnot, but overall I think it's just more hassle than it's worth.
Personal advantages of the swag:
- Get to use the awning during the day. I can just drag the swag to the other side of the car during the day and not have to bother with setup/tear down.
- Can ditch both the sleeping pads and only carry the swag and a sleeping bag.
- If we decided to leave camp for the day I only need to pack the awning. I don't mind leaving stuff behind to mark the site as occupied.
- Quicker setup than the awning room and I'm assuming it packs up easier than trying to cram a 3-dimensional box into a bag. Last night I purchased some cam straps, hoping those may help with rolling up the room and getting it tight.
- Swag will handle heavy wind and rain better than the awning room
I really wanted as oztent but they take up way more room than the awning room, and I'm still stuck with all the sleeping pads, so they don't really help my situation much. And even though they advertise them as 30 second tents, you still will need to secure them with guy wires in any sort of bad weather. Only knock against the swag is the size and having to strap something else to my roof rack.
To answer a couple of the question I saw in this thread
Yes you can use the cram method for the awning room, but it may take a try or two. As far as attaching the ARB wind breaks, I believe you can only use the ones that attach to the side, not the one that attaches to the side furthest from the vehicle. The awning room attached to a rail on the far side and I think the wind break attaches the same way. The side panel wind breaks just attach with velcro loops around the horizontal poles which you can still access with the awning room attached. I can't speak for all knockoff awnings, but my ARB room attached just fine to my $80 ebay awning.