Brakes seizing after wheel spin/left foot braking

Gary Franks

New member
I have repeatedly experienced my service brakes seizing (applied) immediately following an offroad incidence of wheel spin and/or application of left foot braking during a wheel spin in 4H and 4L.

When this occurs, I wait patiently (more than 5 minutes, less than 30) and do nothing and the brakes will release by themselves and I’m back to normal.

My Jeep is a 2008 Wrangler Unlimited Sahara 4x4, automatic transmission with optional factory Trac-Lok Limited Slip Rear Differential and 3.73 axle ratio. Stock wheels and suspension. All recalls have been applied (12/23/10).

It has taken several incidents over several offroad trips to identify the circumstances that cause the brake seizing and how it gets corrected.

The first time that it happened, I was in 4H driving on sand dunes and on two occasions that day I got somewhat stuck and one or more wheels were spinning. I may have been using left foot braking in an attempt to reduce spinning. Once I was unstuck and driving again, I noticed that the vehicle seemed sluggish and discovered that the brakes were locked up as I was driving.

I stopped and began futile attempts to correct the problem: changing from 4H to 2H and to N to 4L; pressing the ESP button; tapping the brakes while driving; pulling the IOD fuse. In the meantime, my girlfriend was busy reading the Owner’s Manual (there’s an owner’s manual?!:)). She read the part about pressing and holding the ESP button for five seconds to “fully” disable the ESP. That seemed to work – we thought. In retrospect, we have concluded that the brakes coincidently released themselves about that moment.

The last time that this occurred, I was in 4L, therefore ESP was definitely off. Again, I got myself in a bad spot, one or more wheels were spinning, and I may or may not have used the left foot on the brake (I’m not sure). This time, I absolutely did not attempt any corrective measures (changing gears, etc.) and the brakes released themselves after 10 to 30 minutes. In fact, as I sat quietly and patiently waiting, I could hear and feel the brakes periodically creak as they eased up.

Could this be just a crazy ECM computer? Could this be something mechanical? It does not seem to be related to ambient temperature (some instances were in hot weather, but not all). It does not seem to be related to overheated brakes because I was not riding the brakes or using them excessively as I might have if I were going down a long hill. Although it sounds as though they are easing up as they cool, maybe it is just slowly losing pressure.

In some instances (not all), the “ESP BAS” malfunction light will turn on after the incident. I don’t recall any warning lights coming on during the actual wheel spin (I’m not 100% sure). I must confess, after having read the Owner’s Manual section on ESP, I don’t think that I really understand what the difference is between “partial off” and “fully off”.

Obviously, I will be taking the Jeep to the dealer soon, but I wanted to get your comments first so that I could properly advise the service advisor. Sorry for the long post. Thanks for your input. I’ll report back when I know something definitively.
 

Gary Franks

New member
Well, I dropped off the Jeep at the dealer this morning along with a copy of my posting from here. Assuming that the dealer does something to the Jeep, the next step will be to find some slippery soil and some hills nearby to test if they fixed it.
 

Black Dog

Makin' Beer.
My jeep does the same thing when I ride the brakes like on a muddy\slushy road when I'm on a decline or going around a corner. Actually the first time it did it to me I was about 13-14 miles up a forest service road and was wondering if I should start walking or not. Best thing I could come up with though is that I either had water or an air bubble in my brake lines. In either case the fix would be to bleed the brakes and top off the fluid. I haven't tested or confirmed that yet because I haven't been driving my jeep much, but I'm about 95% positive thats what it is.
 

Gary Franks

New member
My jeep does the same thing when I ride the brakes like on a muddy\slushy road when I'm on a decline or going around a corner. ... In either case the fix would be to bleed the brakes and top off the fluid.
You were in 4wd at the time? Did the brakes release on their own or did you have to actually bleed the brake line each time?
 

Black Dog

Makin' Beer.
Most of the time I was only in 2 wheel drive, but it did it in 4h also. I would do the same as you and just wait until they released then keep driving and try to use my breaks as little as possible. Its always my front left break that grabs, so I'm guessing that I'll need to rebuild\replace the calipers. Rotors and pads are barely a year old.
 

98roamer

Explorer
My Corolla did the same thing. Anything that keeps the pads rubbing on the rotor will heat them up and tighten on the rotor. It might be crap in the calipers keeping them from sliding away from the rotors. My corolla was old brake lines that wouldn't release the brake fluid fast enough due to crap blocking the ports.
 

Gary Franks

New member
No resolution yet, but more tests

At this moment, the issue has not been resolved… but the story gets more interesting…

Jeep dealer mechanic (per Chrysler’s request) wanted to test the vehicle with the ABS module disconnected. There is no dirt testing terrain anywhere near the dealership, so I offered to take the Jeep out to the dirt and conduct the test as they requested. My instructions were to attempt to recreate the problem with the ABS module disconnected. The theory was that if it occurred while the ABS control module was disconnected, it would indicate a mechanical issue with the valves; if it did NOT occur while the ABS module was disconnected, they would replace the control module.

So, I finally found a single dirt hill for testing about 45 minutes from the dealership (Orange County, California does not have much for offroading). I was able to recreate the problem while spinning wheels with left-foot braking in 4L. The brakes seized up. I disconnected the ABS module while the brakes were still seized, no change. I maneuvered to a different hill position, left the ABS module disconnected, left the e-brake off, left the Jeep in neutral and shut down the Jeep. I waited in the driver’s seat and after some time, the brakes released themselves and I began to roll down the hill.

I then attempted to recreate the problem with the ABS module disconnected. I was unable to recreate the problem. Sundown came and I suspended my tests. I returned to the same place the next day, disconnected the ABS control module again and attempted unsuccessfully to recreate the problem for nearly 20 minutes of maneuvering, slipping and spinning with left-foot braking.

I returned the Jeep to the dealership and now Chrysler is insisting that the mechanic perform the test himself. Now I’m waiting for the mechanic to negotiate with Chrysler and/or get permission from his manager to go offroad with me.

I am now waiting for common sense to prevail and for them to just replace the ABS control module.
 

Sal-XK

Observer
Don't wait for common sense to prevail for to long you might turn to dust waiting for that to happen.
 

4Rescue

Expedition Leader
Are you using your left foot to brake to trick the LSD into locking up???? I can assume that since the ABS mod. was disco'd that you've got a mechanical fault of some sort. Sure sounds like a hydraulic problem to me. If there's a leak or bubble often the brakes won't work initialy but it sounds like the oposite is happening to you.

Best bet, when you take it OR for now just disco. the ABS. DOn't need those off-road anyway do ya???

Seems like the more people do to make driving easier, the harder it get's to make the rig last any ammount of time before a fault. THAT is why I like my manual everything eh ;) Besides, you've already got a couple "built in ABS sensors" ... THey're called your Hind-quarters and your noodle (Aka you butt and your brain eh) I find these tend to not get confused as much as a sensor and computer that are esentialy blind untill asked to perform a task.

Cheers

Dave
 

Gary Franks

New member
Good progress

Ok, some good news… Jeep dealer mechanic phoned me to tell me that he did some testing on his own and confirmed my test results. I didn’t ask the mechanic where he took my Jeep to test this because I thought that he might be just making up the story to satisfy Chrysler and move ahead with replacing the ABS control module for me. He did advise me that he won’t have time to test it for me after he replaces the module – that’s okay with me too – that’s gives me a good excuse to go offroad again.

So, I’m off to the dirt this weekend to see if I can get stuck, spin my wheels and not cause any problems and I will provide my final report.

Additional lesson learned here… There’s nowhere to go offroad near my home! I have to travel at least 45 minutes to get to some dirt! The areas around my home have intriguing names: Big Canyon, Promontory Point, Harbor Ridge, Spyglass Hill, Eastbluff, Turtle Rock; but the only dirt here is in a plastic bag on the back end of a gardening truck and the only place to truly go offroad here is to put the Jeep on the Balboa Island Ferry! Don’t feel too sorry for me though, I do have the beach!
Are you using your left foot to brake to trick the LSD into locking up????
Yes, in some cases. Other times I was just trying to hold my position on a hill as I attempted to maneuver the Jeep into a better position for traction.
I can assume that since the ABS mod. was disco'd that you've got a mechanical fault of some sort.
Yes, the dashboard was well lit with warning messages.
 

mcneil

Observer
Additional lesson learned here… There’s nowhere to go offroad near my home! I have to travel at least 45 minutes to get to some dirt! The areas around my home have intriguing names: Big Canyon, Promontory Point, Harbor Ridge, Spyglass Hill, Eastbluff, Turtle Rock; but the only dirt here is in a plastic bag on the back end of a gardening truck and the only place to truly go offroad here is to put the Jeep on the Balboa Island Ferry! Don’t feel too sorry for me though, I do have the beach!

I hear you. San-Angeles sucks. I live 400 yds from the border of the national forest, and I have to drive for about an hour to find dirt that's not posted or gated.
 

alosix

Expedition Leader
I hear you. San-Angeles sucks. I live 400 yds from the border of the national forest, and I have to drive for about an hour to find dirt that's not posted or gated.

Guys.. Where i'm from on the East coast it was AT LEAST 3 hours (3.5 doing the speed limit) to get to any dirt. 45 minutes to me is like having it right next door :)
 

JKIslander

Observer
Guys.. Where i'm from on the East coast it was AT LEAST 3 hours (3.5 doing the speed limit) to get to any dirt. 45 minutes to me is like having it right next door :)

Thats the truth, im from the same area as alosix was from. 45 minutes would be awesome compared to the 3-4 hours we have to drive
 

Forum statistics

Threads
189,939
Messages
2,922,461
Members
233,156
Latest member
iStan814
Top