What kind of mileage exactly do you get?
I track every tank of fuel in both of my vehicles from the day I've owned them. The van has seen 14 fills over 3300 miles so far that I track with a spreadsheet:
Fill # - Odometer - Miles - Gallons - Cost --- MPG
1..........121340........483.....27.00.....78.49....17.90
2..........121391.........51.......4.00.....11.74....12.75
3..........121748........357.....20.35.....60.24....17.54
4..........121871........123.......7.35.....21.90....16.73
5..........122242........371......22.30.....62.21....16.64
6..........122549........307......20.70.....56.98....14.83
7..........122690........141.......7.29......20.71....19.34*
8..........123015........325......18.55.....55.63....17.52
9..........123319........304......16.85.....54.75....18.04
10........123570.........251.....14.00......48.00...17.93
11........123894.........324.....16.63......51.21...19.48
12........124141.........247.....16.24......51.30...15.21
13........124458.........317.....25.31......87.58...12.52
14........124649.........191.....14.97......54.80...12.76
Total Average to Date = 16.37 MPG
Of that 3300 miles:
2000 miles - Major highway road trip between MI and MA
1300 miles - Very mixed driving. Mostly short trips with a lot of stop'n'go. I live in the greater Boston area where traffic is brutal.
I have a ScanGauge and I definitely see mileage in the 20s when rolling on flat highway with the cruise on. Those higher values of 18-20 MPG were mostly highway miles.
Starting at Fill #7 is when the van was converted to 4x4. Keep in mind that this is a lightly loaded 1/2 ton with the 5.3L V8, 3.42 gears, 265/70-16 all terrain tires, Mobil1 lubricants throughout, fresh filters and burning 87 octane gas. The only thing I haven't done yet is check/replace spark plugs and plug wires. I drive like my grandma, typically setting the cruise at 60-65 MPH and no jack-rabbit-starts from stop lights. How you drive, gears and tire size make the biggest effects.
Vans are about as aerodynamic as a barn so that big top on yours is definitely penalizing you. I'm looking forward to getting rid of the winter blend gas since that typically hurts mileage as well. Hope this helps!