I like the Evoque.
It will never be a Defender rival in serious off road conditions, but it's not designed to do that. You will never treat it in the same way you treat a Defender.
It can cope perfectly well with the mud and snow conditions we get here, i saw a couple moving about quite happily in the snow we had in winter.
It is a small, stylish, good handling light 4x4, yes you can stick a roof rack etc on and it will be a long distance tourer as well, it will take you there in comfort and let you enjoy the views as you travel along.
What it does, is bring loads of new people into the LR brand, it gives a serious cash boost to LR to help them develop new models, same with the new L405 and Sport models.
They all can do the off road driving, change the factory tyres for better off road ones and i'm sure they will go pretty much anywhere you want them to. With respect to the size of the cars.
The l322 was famous for climbing slopes and terrain that the Defender couldn't climb at LR's testing ground. The Evoque has you tube video's of it pulling away on steep hills, with 2 wheels on ice and 2 on tarmac, no fuss, no drama, just a clean pull away. How many of the
Some people moan at how LR lost their way after the Classic went out of production, other's hate air suspension, some hate every LR that doesn't have leaf sprung suspension.
It's called progress, the march of time stands still for nothing. Look at how LR didn't follow the market in the 60s and 70s and lost huge ground to the Jap products who came along, did everything the LR did, but with more powerful engines and a better build and reliability. Even now that market has not been reclaimed. Will it ever be reclaimed?
The older LR's are of their time, a product of innovation and new ideas. How many thought in the 70s that the original 3 door RR would never catch on?
The Evoque is the car for today's time, LR sell a range of fantastic 4x4s for many price ranges, they all have off road capability and good towing for their respective classes.
The fact LR sales continue to rise every year is down to seeing what the market want's and making car's to suit it, you can't please everyone though and while some may hate it, other's will love it.
For every one sold, there is more money to develop the next Defender, so that alone should have people wishing it to continue to be a sales success.