05 MKIII or Classic. Stay away from P38 headaches.
05 is nice because it still has the BMW like the 03 and 04, but with a newer nav system. I hear the Jag engine and 6 speed box is nice and smoother, but I would rather trust the 7 series beemer engine. I feel a Brit with a German is better than two Brits in bed
The classic varies between years. I am about to get a 95 because I like the interior. Some hate it, some like it, but its a hell of a lot nicer than my Defender. But in the end the Classic is easier to work on and fix opposed to the MKIII models.